An Effective Protocol for the Production of Primary and Secondary Somatic Embryos in Cauliflower (Brassica Oleraceae Var. Botrytis)
Magda Al Shamari1, Hail Z Rihan2* and Michael P Fuller2
1Department of Horticulture Office, Ministry of Agriculture, Iraq
2School of Biological and Marine Sciences, Plymouth University, UK
Submission: January 23, 2018; Published: February 19, 2018
*Corresponding author: Hail Z Rihan, School of Biological and Marine Sciences, Faculty of Science and Engineering, Plymouth University, Plymouth, Devon PL4 8AA, UK, Tel: 00447513724273; Email: hail.rihan@plymouth.ac.uk
How to cite this article: Al Shamari M, Rihan HZ, Fuller MP. An Effective Protocol for the Production of Primary and Secondary Somatic Embryos in Cauliflower (Brassica Oleraceae Var. Botrytis). Agri Res & Tech: Open Access J. 2018; 14(1): 555908. DOI: 10.19080/ARTOAJ.2018.14.555908
Abstract
An in vitro regeneration protocol based on the use of root-derived embryogenic callus tissue was established. Three different sizes of explants were tested in order to determine the optimal size of explants for somatic embryo production. The best formation of somatic embryos was on explant size 600-1000^m achieved using 90sec duration of blending. Kinetin played an important role in somatic embryo induction, development and maturation. Embryo maturation occurred on the medium with the lowest concentration of kinetin (0.5mg L-1).
Normal secondary somatic embryos (SSEs) were induced directly on hypocotyls of primary somatic when cultured on semi solid MS basal medium supplemented with 30g L-1 sucrose in the absence of growth regulators. SSEs completed full development in the same medium. Cyclic secondary somatic embryogenesis was a good source of embryogenic material, which can be used for increasing the efficiency of plantlet regeneration in cauliflower. After 60 days of culture, it was demonstrated that using activated charcoal in the culture medium had no significant effect on SSEs yield and moreover, it had negative impacts on the morphological shape of embryos as most of SSEs were abnormal with split collar cotyledons and were smaller in size. The effective protocol for somatic embryo production designed in this study could have important applications in the field of cauliflower micropropagation and breeding systems.
Keywords: Embryogenic callus tissue; Kinetin; Somatic embryogenesis; Activated charcoal; Primary somatic embryos; Secondary somatic embryos; Abnormal somatic embryos; Cauliflower
Abbreviations: AC: Activated Charcoal; RDECT: Root-derived Embryogenic Callus Tissue
Introduction
Somatic embryogenesis is a multi-step in-vitro regeneration process, which starts with the formation of pro-embryogenic masses followed by somatic embryo formation, maturation, and plant proliferation [1]. The use of in-vitro somatic embryogenesis is preferred over other in-vitro developmental processes such as organogenesis or auxiliary bud propagation, since it can be used for micropropagation or genetic modification Ogita et al. [2] and for rapid proliferation of plants [3,4]. All plant species can probably achieve somatic embryogenesis when the appropriate explant, culture media and environmental conditions are optimised [5]. The efficiency of in vitro proliferation can be determined by explant size Gugsa & Kumlehn [6] and uniform culture conditions, which can be provided by the use of liquid culture systems. The change of medium is easier in the liquid culture production where bigger vessels can be used Sumaryono et al. [7] and the medium can easily be decanted. All of the surfaces of the explants are immersed using liquid medium and therefore nutrient adsorption can occur at all parts of the explants [8].
In most species, auxin and cytokinin are applied as the main plant growth regulators, which induce and allow the development of somatic embryos [9]. Plant growth regulators (PGRs) play an important role at the induction phase of somatic embryogenesis Pacheco et al. [10] and generally, somatic embryogenesis can be promoted by auxin alone George [11] or in combination with cytokinins [12]. Cytokinins can play a role in somatic embryogenesis by promoting cell division of pre- embryogenically determined cells [13].
Secondary embryogenesis, also termed recurrent, repetitive, accessory or proliferative embryogenesis occurs when primary somatic embryos cannot develop to plantlets. Second generation embryos can develop from cotyledons, hypocotyls or roots of primary embryos [14-21]. In this phenomenon a new somatic embryo can be created from existing somatic embryos [22]. The secondary somatic embryogenesis system can be used in plant breeding Shu & Loh [2 3] since repeated cycles of secondary embryogenesis can maintain the “embryogenicity” for prolonged periods of time Raemakers et al. [24] without apparent diminution of embryogenic capacity [23]. It can also be useful for the production of artificial seed [25,26] since unlimited numbers of somatic embryos can be provided by the repetitive culturing [27]. Secondary embryos have been reported in several brassica species such as Brassica rapa (Chinese cabbage) Choi et al. [28] Brassica nigra (Black Mustard) Gupta et al. [29] and Brassica napus (Rapeseed) Shu & Loh [23], Burbulis et al. [30], Koh & Loh [31] but there is little literature on secondary embryogenesis in vegetable brassicas especially in cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis).
In a wide range of plant species, the addition of Activated Charcoal (AC) in culture media generally promotes growth, somatic embryogenesis and organogenesis [32-35]. The applicability of AC in the culture medium comes from its general ability for the adsorption of inhibitory substances Thomas [36] and particularly phenyl acetic acid, benzoic acid derivatives and other colourless toxic compounds produced during embryogenesis [37,38]. In tissue culture, AC often promotes morphogenesis and this might be mainly due to its ability to decrease toxic metabolic brown exudate accumulation and phenolic exudation common in plant tissue culture [36]. In vitro, there are both positive and negative effects of AC depending on different factors especially its concentration, the plant species cultured and the type of explant tissue used [33,39,40].
The current study aimed to optimise an effective protocol for primary and secondary somatic embryo production system in cauliflower This included the determination of the best explant size class that should be used to produce efficient somatic embryo production in cauliflower and the investigation of the influence of kinetin in this process. To our knowledge, there have been no studies reporting the effect of AC on secondary somatic embryos formation in cauliflower and cauliflower has been considered to be recalcitrant to somatic embryogenesis. The work reported here focussed on assessing AC effects on quantitative and qualitative in vitro yield of SSEs from primary somatic embryos
Materials and Methods
Cauliflower somatic embryo production system and the effect of different sizes of root-derived embryogenic callus
Continuous immersion in agitated liquid media technique (CI ALMT) was used to induce somatic embryo formation on the explants of root-derived embryogenic callus tissue (RDECT). Cauliflower cv. White Cloud, was used throughout this study. In this technique, the explants (Figure 1A) were homogenized using a commercial blender (Multi-mixer model no. 50376) (Figure 1B). Blending was made with 50mL of MS basal medium [41]. The explants derived from the blending were then classified into three size classes (300-600, 600-1000 and 1000-2000|im] using commercial sieves (Endecotts Ltd., London) (Figure 1C). After sieving, a consistent volume of explants (74μL) was placed in culture pots containing 30mL of somatic induction medium (SIM) which consisted of 0.05mg L-1 IAA, 0.5mg L-1 Kinetin and 2% sucrose. Five pots of each treatment were placed randomly on an orbital shaker at 150 rpm and supplemented with 16h light (spectral photo fluence 40|imol m-2 s-2) supplied with cool white fluorescent tubes. After 40 days culture, somatic embryos on each explant were observed under a low power light microscope (EMZ-8TR) fitted with a camera (Infinity 2) and the number of embryos counted and developmentally classified.
Optimization of blending duration
Six blending durations (15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90sec) were conducted using 3g of RDECT for each blending treatment. The total amount of explants was evaluated as fresh weight and volume of explants produced from each sieving size class. Two size classes, 600-1000|im and 1000-2000|im, of homogenised RDECT were used in this experiment.
Effects of cytokinin on somatic embryo production
Chopped RDECT of size 600-1000|im were placed on SIM medium supplemented with various concentrations of kinetin (0.5, 1, 2mg L-1) together with 0.5mg L-1 IAA and 20% sucrose to assess the effect of kinetin concentrations on somatic embryo induction, development and maturation. Each treatment consisted of five pots, each containing 30mL of culture medium with a constant volume (74μL) of explants. Callus cultures were grown and developed in this medium for 40 days. The development and maturation of embryos were observed and the number of embryos recorded. The embryogenesis rate was assessed as the number of explants that produced somatic embryo per volume unit used of explants (74μL).
Explant preparation for secondary somatic embryos production
A simplified procedure was developed to produce secondary somatic embryos (SSEs) from primary somatic embryos (PSEs) of cauliflower Primary somatic embryos at the cotyledonary stage were produced from root-derived embryogenic callus tissue on somatic induction medium (SIM). The media consisted of MS supplemented by 0.05mg L-1 1AA (lndole-3-acetic acid), 0.5mg L-1 kinetin and 20% sucrose. Primary somatic embryos were isolated and collected to use as source material for the induction of SSEs.
Secondary somatic embryos production
To find the best medium for secondary somatic embryogenesis and embryo maturation, 25 embryos were used for each treatment, 5 mature PSEs were transferred into each pot (5 pots for each treatment) each containing 30mL of secondary somatic induction medium. Two types of induction medium were used, the first consisted of semi-solid MS medium free of growth regulators plus 30g L-‘ sucrose and the second type was MS medium with activated charcoal at two concentrations (1 and 2g L-‘). The pots were kept (completely randomised) in a growth incubator at 22.5 °C under 16 photoperiod at a light intensity of 80|imolm-2s-1 PAR supplied by cool white fluorescent tubes and this experiment was repeated three times. Secondary somatic embryos were observed and classified (globular, torpedo, heart shaped, cotyledonary) under a low power light microscope (EMZ-8TR) fitted with a camera (Infinity 2). The number and quality of SSEs were recorded after 60 days of culture.
Statistical analysis
Results are presented as means with standard errors (S.E.). All data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) using Minitab software (version 15) and comparisons of means were made with least significant difference test (LSD) at the 95% level of probability.
Results
Effect of kinetin concentration on the formation of somatic embryos
The results revealed that the optimal formation for somatic embryos from RDECT explants was achieved from size class 600-1000μm (P≤0.001) with significant less produced at the higher and lower sieving size classes. The highest value for the somatic embryo number (30.3) was produced from explants size 600-1000μm while poor embryo formation was produced from explants size classes 300-600 and 1000-2000μm (Figure 2).
Effect of blending duration on the volume and weights of explants produced
The results showed that the use of 90 sec blending duration was found to be optimal as it produced the highest amount of explants in terms of fresh weight and volume at the desirable size class (600-1000μm). However, at the 1000-2000μm size class, the highest amount of explants produced was with the 75sec blending duration (P≤0.001) (Figure 3).
Effect of kinetin concentration on the formation of somatic embryos
The results indicated that the medium containing 0.5mg L-1 Kinetin and 0.05mg L-1 IAA produced the maximum total number of somatic embryos (30.9 embryo/explants) (P<0.001) with the highest embryogenesis rate 60% (Figure 4 ). It was observed that the development of somatic embryos in this medium was also qualitatively better as the somatic embryos developed sequentially from globular to heart to torpedo and reached cotyledonary stage. While embryogenesis was observed on 57% of explants on the medium supplemented with 1mg L-1 Kin plus 0.05mg L-1 IAA, these stayed mostly at globular and heart stages with only some conversion to the other later stages of development. It was also noted that a high number of somatic embryos on the medium containing 2mg L-1 Kin plus 0.05mg L-1 IAA stayed at the globular stage despite an embryogenesis rate of 55% (Figure 5).
Effect of AC on SSEs production
The results revealed that the use of PSEs as explants led to the formation of secondary embryos on MS basal medium free of hormones supplemented either with or without activated charcoal (AC). SSEs were visible from the PSEs within 60 days of culture. It was observed that a small mass of tissue proliferated from the tissue corresponding to the hypocotyls of primary embryos, after that several SSEs emerged. Different developmental stages of SSEs were noticed. However, secondary embryos developed directly on hypocotyls of primary embryo (Figure 6A). Primary somatic embryos on MS basal medium (free of hormones and AC) exhibited the best induction for normal SSEs (embryos with two cotyledons) producing 9.2 embryo/ explants (Tables 1 & 2) but there were no significant differences between treatments in terms of total number of SSEs (Tables 1 & 2).
Two abnormal morphological types of SSEs were observed. When AC was added to the media, embryos with split collar cotyledons (Figure 6B) were obtained on MS medium plus 1 and 2g L-1 AC while abnormal SSEs with four cotyledons were sometimes observed on plain MS induction medium. The size of secondary embryos that formed on MS medium without AC differed significantly (P≤0.001) and the highest average of embryo size (4.2mm) was achieved using AC free medium. However, the PSEs could bear smaller SSEs along their hypocotyl region when placed on medium with AC.
The results also showed that the MS medium supplemented with 1 and 2gL"‘ AC had a positive effect on subsequent shoot formation as these media led to few shoots being formed (1.6 and 2.4 shoots) using 1 and 2gL-1 respectively and no shoots formed on AC free MS medium (Tables 1 & 2).
Discussion
Using the continuous immersion in agitated liquid media technique (CI ALMT), somatic embryos were readily produced from explants of root derived embryogenic callus tissue (RDECT). The direct and indirect regeneration of somatic embryos on explants depended largely on the size of the explants. This emphasises the need to empirically optimize the explant size [5]. Many histological studies on somatic embryogenesis induction have suggested that somatic embryogenesis starts with active division in embryogenic callus which then develops into an embryo-like structure that then advances through the familiar globular, heart, torpedo and cotyledonary developmental stages [42-46]. In the current study, although somatic embryos with all developmental stages were produced in callus cultures from all the explants size classes tested, significant numbers of somatic embryos was only achieved in cultures produced from explant size class 600-1000 μm with many less from both smaller and larger explant sizes. In sweet potato, it was similarly observed that the decrease in the size of cell aggregates can lead to a reduction in somatic embryos produced [47]. Shigeta & Sato [48] cultured horseradish embryogenic callus in MS liquid medium and after four weeks, somatic embryos were only obtained from a cell aggregate size of 1000 μm or less in diameter Wannarat [49] obtained horseradish somatic embryos from specific sized cell aggregates ranging from 1000-3000 μm in diameter whilst Chen et al. [50] reported that the smaller pieces of embryogenic calli that were derived from leaflets of sexual bahiagrass which were less than or equal to 2000μm in diameter appeared uniform in size and hadabilities for regeneration. Jain et al. [51] mentioned that the development of date palm callus growth and improvement of synchronized somatic embryos can be achieved when fine chopping of embryogenic callus into small pieces <380μm was applied.
When using mechanical blending techniques, it is important to determine the best blending duration and here it was noted that the amount of cauliflower explants produced for a desirable size class differed with blending durations used. It was demonstrated that increasing blending duration to 90sec led to the production of a good amount of explants at size class 600- 1000μm. The use of a blending technique has also been used effectively to produce suspension cultures from callus tissues of Capsicum frutescens Williams et al. [52] and to homogenize callus tissues [53-56].
Plant growth regulators can play essential roles in somatic embryogenesis induction Toonen & Devries [57] but the requirements of auxin and cytokinin and their levels have to be determined empirically for each plant species [58]. Cytokinins appear to have a role in the initial cell division phase of somatic embryogenesis Danin et al. [59] and the responsibility for the establishment and maintenance of embryo apical meristems can be achieved by cytokinins [7]. In Brassica rapa, the presence of growth regulators in the basal medium led to the development of somatic embryos [60]. Kinetin in combination with auxin, particularly IAA was used to produce somatic embryos in cauliflower Pareek & Chandra [61] and our findings showed that the growth and development of somatic embryos were influenced by Kinetin concentration. Globular embryos developed into heart and torpedo shaped embryos and converted into cotyledonary shapes faster on media containing low concentrations of Kinetin (0.5mg L-1). Moreover, a high number of embryos on media containing 1 or 2mg L-1 Kinetin with 0.05mg L-1 IAA could not develop to the cotyledonary stage. This effect of high level of cytokinin partially or totally inhibiting the development of somatic embryo cotyledons has also been reported previously by Ammirato [62].
Secondary embryos are thought to arise directly from epidermal or sub epidermal cells of cotyledons or hypocotyls [63]. In the current study the appearance of secondary embryos was from the hypocotyl region of primary somatic embryos after 60 days of culture and this in accordance with Kumar & Shekhawat [64] who commented that prolonged culturing leads to the proliferation of secondary embryos. According to our results and others studies conducted on Brassica nigra Gupta et al. [29] and Brassica napus [30,65-67] report the production of secondary embryos using MS medium free of growth regulators. Gupta et al. [29] had concluded that six to seven secondary embryos were obtained from Brassica nigra protoplast-derived embryos. Also in Chinese cabbage, a few secondary embryos were formed on the surface of somatic embryos [28]. Habituated cultures can be defined as the cultures that have the ability to proliferate in culture medium in the absence of exogenous growth regulators [68]. In some species, the maturation of embryos does not require additional culture steps Raemakers et al. [24] and this appears to be the case with cauliflower, where the secondary somatic embryos developed and matured on the same induction medium.
Somatic embryos can be classified into normal or aberrant (morphologically abnormal in size and shape or lacking distinct stages) [69]. In the current work it was demonstrated that the yield of normal SSEs did not improve significantly when AC was added to the medium. A similar effect was previously reported by Aderkas et al. [70] with somatic embryo production of hybrid larch. The development of abnormal somatic embryos such as the split-collar cotyledon somatic embryos can be obtained when changes in auxin distribution or activity occur during the transition from globular to heart stage. During transition, the separation of the emerging cotyledonary primordial ring into two parts occurs, and by this process bilateral symmetry is achieved around the apical-basal axis. Polar transport for auxin can play an essential role in this process. Polar transport leads to the removal of auxin from the area between the two emerging cotyledon primordia as well as providing a continuous transport for auxin which is a prerequisite until the separation of the cotyledon primordia can be observed morphologically. The split-collar cotyledons occur when the partial separation of the cotyledons is obtained [71]. In the current study the appearance of split collar cotyledon embryos was on media containing AC and it has previously been reported that AC can adsorb auxin from culture media Constantin et al. [72] including perhaps excessive quantities of both exogenously supplied and tissue- produced auxins [73]. This suggests that, the absorption of auxin that is released by the embryos to the medium during embryo development may interfere with morphology and germination of embryos [74]. We suggest that AC may have an effect on internal auxin concentration and its activity resulting in the appearance of abnormal SSEs with the split-collar cotyledons shape. The other abnormal shape that appeared in the current study on MS medium was embryos with four cotyledons. Abnormal somatic embryos with more than two cotyledons have been observed before [75,76] and has been described previously in cauliflower by Leroy et al. 2000. This might be due to prolonged time in culture that can cause accumulation of mutations (somaclonal variations), which can lead to morphological abnormalities such as multiplex apical formation, pluri-cotyledonary structures and fused cotyledons [77]. According to our findings, the SSEs that formed on media enriched with AC appeared morphologically smaller in size (1.4mm) compared with those originating on MS medium devoid of AC (4.2mm). In contrast Pintos et al. [78] commented that a significant increase in a relative size of cork oak somatic embryos can be enhanced using AC in the medium and embryo size increased to reach 1.3cm in length. A compromise between the number and quality of SEs developed and the use of AC has been always complex and species specific and some authors maintain that the use of AC in embryogenesis remains questionable [79].
Another observation in the current study was the development of some shoots by direct organogenesis from hypocotyls of primary somatic embryos in the presence of AC. Previously, it was reported that a stimulative effect on the growth and organogenesis of different plants is achieved when AC is added to the culture medium [80]. Similarly, Nayanakantha et al. [81] found that the addition of AC to MS medium led to shoot induction and multiplication of Aloe vera.
Conclusion
A reliable method was developed to produce somatic embryos from RDECT of cauliflower and the optimization of culture conditions for induction and development of somatic embryos was determined. It was clear that the use of CI ALMT with root derived explants was a very efficient tool for the high proliferation of somatic embryos of cauliflower. The explant size had an overriding effect in terms of the number of somatic embryos produced and the exogenous Kinetin level affected both the development and maturation of the somatic embryos.
It was also concluded that primary somatic embryos can be successfully used to produce secondary somatic embryos in cauliflower. It was found that the use of MS medium devoid of growth regulators could be very efficient for the good proliferation of normal secondary somatic embryos of cauliflower. The addition of activated charcoal to the medium did not enhance the production of SSEs and led to some malformations.
Acknowledgement
We would like to thank the Iraq Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research (MOHESR) for the award of scholarship provided to Al Sharmi that provided the financial support for this research project.
References
- Vonarnold S, Sabala S, Bozhkov P, Dyachok J, Filonova L (2002) Development pathways of somatic embryogenesis. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult 69(3): 233-249.
- Ogita S, Uefuji H, Chol Y, Hyatanaka T, Ogawa M, et al. (2002) Genetic modification of coffee plants. J Plant Biotec 3: 91-94.
- Aryas S, Aryas ID, Eriksson T (1993) Rapid multiplication of adventitious somatic embryos of Panax ginseng. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 34(2): 157-162.
- Aryas ID, Rana PK, Arya S (2005) Tissue culture studies on Bambusa polymorpha. In: Trivedi PC (Ed.), Advances in biotechnology. Agrobios Jodhpur, India.
- Edwin GF, Michael A Hall, Geert-Jan De Klerk (2007) Plant propagation by tissue culture: volume 1. The background. Vol. 1. Springer Science & Business Media.
- Gugsa L, Kumlehn J (2011) Somatic Embryogenesis and Massive Shoot Regeneration from Immature Embryo Explants of Tef. Biotech Research International 2011: 1-7.
- Sumaryono, Riyadil I, Kasi PD, Ginting G (2008) Growth and differentiation of embryogenic callus and somatic embryos of oil palm (Elaeis guineensis Jacq.) in temporary immersion system. Indonesian J Agricut 1(2): 109-114.
- Etienne H, Berthouly M (2002) Temporary immersion systems in plant micropropagation. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 69(3): 215-231.
- Feher A, Pasternak TP, Dudits D (2003) Transition of somatic plant cells to an embryogenic state. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 74(3): 201-228.
- Pacheco G, Gagliardi RF, Garneiro LA, Callado CH, Valls JFM, et al. (2007) The role of BAP in somatic embryogenesis induction from seed explants of Arachis species from sections Erectoides and Procumbentes. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 88: 121-126.
- George EF (1993) Plant propagation by tissue culture. The technology. Edington, Wilts, Exegetic Limited, UK.
- Pacheco G, Gagliardi RF, Garneiro LA, Callado CH, Valls JFM, et al. (2007) The role of BAP in somatic embryogenesis induction from seed explants of Arachis species from sections Erectoides and Procumbentes. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 88: 121-126.
- Kintzios S, Sereti E, Bluchos P, Drossopoulos JB, Kitsaki CK, et al. (2002) Growth regulator pretreatment improves somatic embryogenesis from leaves of squash (Cucurbita pepo L.) and melon (Cucurbita melo L.). Plant Cell Rep 21(1): 1-8.
- Gui Y, Guo Z, Ke S, Skirvin RM (1991) Somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration in Acanthopanax senticosus. Plant Cell Rep 9(9): 514516.
- Kato M (1989) Poly ploids of camellia through culture of somatic embryos. Hort Sci 24(6): 1023-1025.
- Maheswaran G, Willams EG (1986) Direct secondary somatic embryogenesis from immature sexual embryos of Trifolium repens cultured in vitro. Ann Bot 57: 109-117.
- Maheswaran G, Willams EG (1986) Primary and Secondary Direct Somatic Embryogenesis from Immature Zygotic Embryos of Brassica campestris. J Plant Physio 124: 4SS-463.
- Plata E, Vieitez AM (1990) In vitro regeneration of camellia reticulata by somatic embryogenesis. Hortic Sci 6S(6): 707-714.
- Polito VS, Granahan MC, Pinney K, Leslie C (1989) Origin of somatic embryos from repetitively embryogenic cultures of walnut (Juglans regia L.): Implications for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Plant Cell Rep 8(4): 219-221.
- Tenning P, Weich EW, Kjarsgaard UB, Lelu MA, Nihlgard M (1992] Somatic embryogenesis from zygotic embryos of sugar beet Beta vulgaris L. Plant Sci 81: 103-109.
- Vieitez AM, Barciela J (1990) Somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration from embryogenic tissues of Camellia japonica L. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 21(3): 267-274.
- Vasic D, Alibert G, Skoric D (2001) Protocols for efficient repetitive and secondary somatic embryogenesis in Helianthus maximiliani (Schrader). Plant Cell Rep 20(2): 121-12S.
- Shu W, Loh CS (1987) Secondary embryogenesis in long- term cultures of winter oil seed rape, Brassica napus spp. oleifera. New Phytol 107(1): 39-46.
- Raemakers CJJM, Jacobsen E, Visser RGF (199S) Secondary somatic embryogenesis and applications in plant breeding. Euphytica 81(1): 93-107.
- McKersie BD, Senaratna T, Bowley SR, Brown DCW, Krochko JE, et al. (1989) Application of artificial seed technology in the production of hybrid alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). In Vitro Cell Dev Bio 2S(12): 11831188.
- Slade D, Fujii JA, Redenbaugh K (1989) Artificial seeds: a method for the encapsulation of somatic embryos. J Tiss Cult Meth 12: 179-184.
- Parrott WA, Bailey MA (1993) Characterization of recurrent somatic embryogenesis of alfalfa on auxin-free medium. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 32(1): 69-76.
- Choi PS, Soh WY, Liu JR (1996) Somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration in cotyledonary explant cultures of Chinese cabbage. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 44(3): 2S3-2S6.
- Gupta V, Aghihotri A, Jagannathan V (1990) Plant regeneration from callus and protoplasts of Brassica nigra (IC2S7) through somatic embryogenesis. Plant Cell Rep 9(8): 427-430.
- Burbulis N, Kupriene R, Liakas V (2007) Somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration in immature zygotic embryos of Brassica napus. Acta Universitatis Latviensis 723: 27-3S.
- Koh WL, Loh CS (2000) Direct somatic embryoenesis, plant regeneration and in vitro flowering in rapid -cycling brassica napus. Plant Cell Rep 19: 1177-1183.
- Ernst R (1974) The use of activated charcoal in a symbiotic seedling culture of Paphiopedilum. Am. Orchid Soc Bull 43: 3S-38.
- Fridborg G, Eriksson T (197S) Effects of activated charcoal on growth and morphogenesis in cell cultures. Physiol Plant 34(4): 306-308.
- Nakamura A, Itagaki R (1973) Anther culture in Nicotiana and the characteristics of the haploid plants . Jpn J Breed 23(2): 71-78.
- Wang PJ, Huang LC (1976) Beneficial effects of activated charcoal on plant tissue and organ cultures. In Vitro 12(3): 260-262.
- Thomas TD (2008) The role of activated charcoal in plant tissue culture. Biotechnnol Adv 26(6): 618-631.
- Drew RLK (1972) Effect of activated charcoal on embryogenesis and regeneration of plantlets from suspension cultures of carrot (Daucus carota L.). Ann Bot 44(3): 387-389.
- Srangsam A, Kanchanapoom K (2003) Thidiazuron induced plant regeneration in callus culture of triploid banana (Musa spp.) 'Gros Michel', AAA group. Songklanakarin J Sci and Tech 2S: 6B9-696.
- Ahuja A (19BS) In vitro shoot differentiation in Eucalyptus citriodora Hook: effect of activated charcoal. Ind J F B: 340-341.
- Pan MJ, Staden J (199B) The use of charcoal in in vitro culture- A review. Plant Growth Regul 26(3): 1SS-163.
- Murashige T, Skoog F (1962) A revised medium for rapid growth and bioassays with tobacco tissue cultures. Physiol Plant 1S(3): 473-497.
- Alemanno L, Berthouly M, Micahaux-Ferriere N (1996) Histology of somatic embryogenesis from floral tissues cocoa. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 46(3): 1B7-194.
- Quiroz-Figueroa F, Mendez-Zeel M, Sanchez-Teyer F, Rojas-Herrera R, Loyola-Vargas VM (2002) Differential gene expression in embryogenic and non-embryogenic clusters from cell suspension cultures of Coffea arabica. J Plant Physiol 1S9: 1267-1270.
- Azpeitia A, Chan JL, Saenz L, Oropeza C (2003) Effect of 22(S),23(S)- homobrassinolide on somatic embryogenesis in plumule explants of Cocos nucifera(L.) cultured in vitro. Hortic Sci Biotechno 7B(S): S91- S96.
- Mandal AKA, Gupta SD (2003) Somatic embryogenesis of safflower: Influence of auxin and ontogeny of somatic embryos. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 72(1): 27-31.
- Sharma SK, Millam S (2004) Somatic embryogenesis in Solanum tuberosum L.: A histological examination of key developmental stages. Plant Cell Rep 23(3): 11S-119.
- Chee RP, Cantliffe DJ (19B9) Composition of embryogenic suspension cultures of Ipomoea batatas Poir. and production of individualized embryos. Plant Cell Tissue Org Cult 17(1): 39-S2.
- Shigeta JI, Saro K (1994) Plant regeneration and encapsulation of somatic embryos of horseradish. Plant Sci (Limerick) 102(1): 109-11S.
- Wannarat W (2009) Somatic embryogenesis of pathogen-free horseradish (Armoracia rustican) plants in vitro. University of Illinois, USA.
- Chen L, Guan L, Anami E, Adachi T (2001) Establishment of Embryogenic Suspension Culture Derived from Leaflets of Sexual Bahiagrass (Paspalum notatum) with Regeneration Ability in Long Term. Plant Biotech 1B: 209-214.
- Jain SM, Al-Khayri JM, Johnson DV (2011) Date palm biotech. Springer Science and Business media B.V, London, UK.
- Williams PD, Willkinson AK, Lewis JA, Black GM, Mavitum F (19BB) A method for the rapid production of fine plant cell suspension cultures. Plant Cell Rep 7(6): 4S9-462.
- Rihan HZ, Al-Issawi M, Burchett S, Fuller MP (2011) Encapsulation of cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var botrytis) microshoots as artificial seeds and their conversion and growth in commercial substrates. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult. (PCTOC) 107(2): 243-2S0.
- Rihan HZ, Al-Issawi M, Al Shamari M, Woldie WA, Kiernan M, et al. (2014) The effect of molybdenum on the molecular control of cold tolerance in cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis) artificial seeds. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult (PCTOC) 11B(2): 21S-22B.
- Rihan HZ, Al-Issawi M, Fuller MP (2017) An analysis of the development of cauliflower seed as a model to improve the molecular mechanism of abiotic stress tolerance in cauliflower artificial seeds. Plant Physiol Biochem 116: 91-10S.
- Wu J, Seliskar DM, Gallagher JL (2005) The response of plasma membrane lipid composition in callus of the halophyte Spartina patens (Poaceae) to salinity stress1. Am J Bot 92: BS2-BSB.
- Toonen MAJ, Devries SC (1996) Initiation of somatic embryos from single cells. Bios Scientific Publishers, Oxford, USA.
- Jain S, Gupta P, Newton R (2000) Somatic embryogenesis in woody plants. Dordrecht, Kluwer Acadamic Publishers, The Netherlands.
- Danin M, Upfold SJ, Levin N, Nadel BL, Alatman A, et al. (1993) Polyamines and cytokinins in celery embryogenic cell cultures. Plant Growth Regul 12(3): 245-254.
- Cao MQ, Li Y, Lui F, Dore C (1994) Embryogenesis and plant regeneration of pakchoi (Brassica rapa L.ssp.chinensis) via in vitro isolated microspore culture. Plant Cell Rep 13(8): 447-450.
- Pareeek LK, Chandra N (1978) Somatic embryogenesis in leaf callus from cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. Botrytis). Plant Sci Lett 11: 311-316.
- Ammirato PV (1985) Patterns of development in culture. In: Henke RR, Hughes KW, et al. (Eds.), Tissue culture in frostry and agriculture. Plenum, New York, USA, p. 9-29.
- Thomas E, Hoffman F, Potrykus I, Wenzel G (1976) Protoplast regeneration and stem embyogenesis of haploid androgenetic rape. Mol Gen Genet 145: 245-247.
- Kumar A. Shekhawat NS (2009) Plant tissue culture and molecular markers. Their role in improving crop productivity. IK International publishing house PVT. Ltd, New Delhi, India, pp. 202.
- Keller WA, Armstrong KC (1977) Embryogenesis and plant regeneration in Brassica napus anther cultures. Can J Bot 55(10): 1383-1388.
- Loh CS, Ingram DS (1982) Production of haploid plants from anther cultures and secondary embryoids of winter oilseed rape, Brassica napus ssp. oleifera. New Phytol 91(3): 507-516.
- Loh CS, Ingram D (1983) The response of haploid secondary embryoids and secondary embryogenic tissues of winter oilseed rape to treatment with colchicine. New Phytol 95(3): 359-366.
- Meins FJ (1989) Habituation: Heritable variation in the requirement of cultured plant cells for hormones. Annu Rev Genet 23: 395-408.
- Raj Bhansali R, Driver JA, Durzan DJ (1990) Rapid multiplication of adventitious somatic embryos in peach and nectarine by secondary embryogenesis. Plant Cell Rep 9(5): 280-284.
- Aderkas PV, Label P, Lelu MA (2002) Charcoal affects early development and hormonal concentrations of somatic embryos of hybrid larch. Tree Physiol 22(6): 431-434.
- Hadfi K, Speth V, Neuhaus G (1998) Auxin-induced developmental patterns in Brassica juncea embryos. Development 125(5): 879-887.
- Constantin MJ, Henke RR, Mansur MA (1977) Effect of activated charcoal on callus growth and shoot organogenesis in tobacco. In Vitro 13(5): 293-296.
- Karunaratne S, Kurukulaarachchi C, Amage GC (1985) A Report on the Culture of Embryos of Dwarf Coconut, Cocos nucifera L var nana In vitro. COCOS 3: 01-08.
- Merkle SA, Parrott WA, Flinn BS (1995) Morphogenic aspects of somatic embryogenesis. In: Thorpe TA (Ed.), In vitro embryogenesis in plants. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, USA, pp. 155-203.
- Choi YE, Kim HS, Soh WY, Yang DC (1997) Developmental and structural aspects of somatic embryos formed on medium containing 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid. Plant Cell Rep 16(11): 738-744.
- Griga M (2002) Morphology and anatomy of Pisum sativum somatic embryos. Biol Plant 45(2): 173-182.
- Evans DA, Sharp WR, Ammirato PV, Yamada Y (1983) Handbook of plant cell culture: Techniques for propagation and breeding. MacMillan, New York, USA.
- Pintos B, Manzanera JA, Bueno MA (2010) Oak somatic and gametic embryos maturation is affected by charcoal and specific aminoacids mixture. Ann For Sci 67(2): 205.
- Lelu-Walter MA, Paques LE (2009) Simplified and improved somatic embryogenesis of hybrid larches (Larix eurolepis and Larix marschlinsii). Perspectives for breeding. Ann For Sci 66(1): 104.
- Mensuali-Sodi A, Panizza M, Serra G, Tognoni F (1993) Involvement of activated charcoal in the modulation of abiotic and biotic ethylene levels in tissuecultures. Sci Hort 54(1): 49-57.
- Nayanakantha NMC, Singh BR, Kumar A (2010) Improved culture medium for micropropagation of Aloe vera L. Tropical Agricultural Research & Extension 13(4): 87-93.