Crop Response to Abiotc Stresses of Effluent, Salinity and Heavy Metal I - Comparative Percentage Seed Germination in Mustard and Wheat
Nidhi Parashar Sharma1 and Ravi Sharma2*
1Department of Chemistry, KR College, India
2Department of Botany, KR College, India
Submission: December 16, 2016; Published: January 20, 2017
*Corresponding author: Ravi Sharma, Department of Botany, KR College, Mathura, 327/Sec-9 Avas Vikas Colony Sikandra Agra 282007 UP, India, Email: drravisharma327@yahoo.com
How to cite this article: Nidhi P S, Ravi S. Crop Response to Abiotc Stresses of Effluent, Salinity and Heavy Metal I - Comparative Percentage Seed Germination in Mustard and Wheat. Agri Res & Tech: Open Access J. 2017; 3(3): 555615. DOI: 10.19080/ARTOAJ.2017.03.555615
Abstract
The results in relation to the effect of different concentrations of the three types of environmental (abiotic) stresses viz., Stress I (Effluent); Stress 11 (Salinity); Stress Ill (Heavy metal) under varying concentration levels (0, 25, 50, 75 & 100 % (Stress 1); 0, 4, 8, 12 & 16 EC dsm-1 (Stress 11) and 0, 100, 200 & 300 ppm (Stress 111) with distilled water as control on germination performance measured in terms of percent germination after 24, 48, 72, 96 and 120 hours of sowing. For these studies two important crops of the region, one legume crop (Mustard - L; family Brassicaceae) and another cereal crop (Wheat - L; family Poaceae/Gramineae), were taken for screening. Interestingly it has been observed that with increasing stress seed germination is delayed as well as reduced. There was also a differential response in percentage germination and tolerance to different types of stresses with respect to crops grown. Results have shown that the highest average germination percentage (GP) of 95.233% was observed in the crop Wheat in 50% of Stress 1 at 120 hours while lowest GP of 1.000% was also observed in the crop Wheat in 300 ppm of Stress 111 at 72 hours. Besides, both the crops Mustard and Wheat did not show any seed germination at all in 100% (Stress 1), 16 dsm-1 (Stress 11) and 300 ppm (Stress 111) concentrations at 24 hours and in 300 ppm (Stress 111) at 48 hours also. Further, it was observed that 75% (Stress 1), 12 dsm-1 (Stress 11) and 200 ppm (Stress 11l) concentrations for three types of stresses and also 72 hours of germination were found to be quite critical for the two crops, therefore, on the basis of percent over control at 72 hours with 75% (Stress 1), 12 dsm-1 (Stress 11) and 200 ppm (Stress 111) concentrations respectively the germination percentage in the two crops showed a trend as percent change over control: Stress I (Effluent) - Mustard [45.150% (-28.021)], Wheat [38.450% (-43.412)]; Stress II (Salinity) - Mustard [38.483% (-38.650)], Wheat [35.450% (-47.827)] and Stress III (Heavy Metal) - Mustard [14.817% (-76.379)], Wheat [10.783% (-84.130)]showing better performance of the leguminous crop than the cereal crop.
Keywords: Seed germination; Effluent; Salt; Heavy metal; Stress; Legume crop; Cereal crop
Introduction
An increasingly greater concern for water quality problem has been shown for the past few decades due to steep rise in population in cities and urban areas. Unprecedented and rapid industrial development, un-thoughtful use of natural resources and building of huge urban complexes are responsible for changing the natural pattern creating several environmental pollution problems causing water quality deterioration. Though development in the modern sense as a whole is blamed for most of the water quality problems but urbanization has been the major cause and the centre of the problem. 1n India water quality of fresh waters both surface and ground water has been a subject of much investigation, however, most of these studies assume the ecosystem as a separate entity and attempts have rarely been made to study the problem in larger aspects as studying drinking and irrigational problems with reference to the water demand, pollution load, degree of treatment, ecological process including effects on animals, human being and vegetation especially our crop plant Sharma [1], Parashar [2], Pathak [3], Saraswat [4], Snehlata [5], Parashar et al. [2] as studied in the present investigation. Environmental Problems in Mathura with special reference to Yamuna River water problems were studied by Sharma [6], Sharma [1], Parashar [7]The present study is an effort an aims at detailed study of potential water quality problems in the light of industrial and urban development in Mathura, UP (India) with an attempt to see its impact on plant growth and development, vis-a-vis on animal and human population, especially agricultural crops of the region so that the quality of city and industrial effluent water of Yamuna River is best utilized for irrigation to raise higher crop yield.
Experimental Materials and Methods
We know a continuous deficit of good-quality fresh water implies that agriculture must use alternative resources such as saline water and sewage and industrial effluents for increasing agricultural production for ever-growing population besides abating pollution of our major river systems and other waterbodies as such to evaluate the effects of water quality as city and industrial effluent and soils irrigated, seed lots of certain crops were screened for their relative tolerance to three types ofenvironmental abiotic stresses viz., Stress I (City and industrial effluents); Stress II (Saline water as sodium chloride NaCl) and Stress III (Heavy metal mercury as HgCl2) under varying concentration levels viz., 0, 25, 50, 75 & 100 % (for city & industrial effluents); 0, 4, 8, 12 & 16 EC dsm-1 (for NaCl) and 0, 100, 200 & 300 ppm (for HgCl2). Distilled water was used as control in all the three types of environmental stress treatments.
The physico-chemical analysis for city and industrial effluents (Table 1 and Graph 1a & 1b) was done in respect to water colour, odour, transparency, turbidity, temperature, pH, total alkalinity, free CO2, DO, BOD, COD, TSS, TDS, Cl- , Ca2+, Na+, K+, Mg2+, SO42+, inorganic PO4--, particulate PO4--, total dissolved PO4--, total Kjeldhal PO4--, NH3-N, NO3-N, total Iron and heavy metals (Hg, Cr, Cd, Pb and As) as per methods described Parashar et al. [2]. Significant differences were noticed among all the parameters at 1% level of probability except heavy metals Hg and as when it was found to be significant at 5%. It is an effort and aims at detailed study of potential water quality problems in the light of industrial and urban development in Mathura with an attempt to see further its impact on plant growth and development especially agricultural crops of the region so that the quality of city and industrial effluent water of Yamuna River is best utilized for irrigation to raise higher crop yield.
For these studies two important crops of Mathura region, one legume crop (Mustard -Brassica campestris L; family Brassicaceae) and another cereal crop (Wheat - Triticum aestivum L; family Poaceae/Gramineae), were taken for screening and detailed physiological and biochemical studies. Seeds of the material involved in the present study were procured from the Agriculture Research Centre Raya, Mathura (UP) India.
Screening of crops was carried out after Garrard's Technique Garrard [8] as modified by Sarin & Rao [9], Sharma [10] wherein germination percentage of the two crops was recorded. Observations on the influence of Stress I (Effluent) in the concentrations of 25, 50, 75, 100 (%); Stress II (NaCl salinity) at 4, 8, 12, 16 (dsm-1) of salt solution; Stress III (Heavy metal HgCl2) at 50, 100, 200, 300 (ppm) and the controls (distilled water grown) were recorded at 24 hours interval from 24 hours after sowing up to the end of 120 hours. Germination percentage at each interval in different treatment concentration levels and controls was observed. For this purpose 650 seeds in thirteen Petri dishes with 50 seeds in each Petri dish per treatment (controls and the three treatments with four concentrations) were allowed to grow on moistened filter paper in BOD Incubator at 25± 2 °C. All results with three replicates were analyzed by Analysis of Variance^ (ANOVA) by using completely randomized design (CRD). Critical differences at 1 and 5 percent probability were calculated wherever the results were significant.
Observations and Results
Certified seeds of the two major local varieties of a legume (Mustard) and a cereal (Wheat) crop were screened for their relative tolerance to the three types of environmental stresses viz., Stress I (City & industrial effluents); Stress II (Saline water as sodium chloride NaCl) and Stress III (Heavy metal mercury as HgCl2) under varying concentration levels viz., 0, 25, 50, 75 & 100 percent (Effluents); 0, 4, 8, 12 & 16 EC dsm-1 (Salinity) and 0, 50, 100, 200 and 300 ppm (Heavy Metal). Distilled water was used as control in all the three types of environmental stress treatments. Observations on percent germination were recorded at 24 hours interval from 24 hours after sowing up to the end of 120 hours. It was felt necessary to undertook relative tolerance behaviour of the two major crops of the Mathura Region (Cereal crop Wheat and Legume crop Mustard) to three types of environmental stresses i.e.,
- Stress I
- Stress II
- Stress III under varying concentration levels in order to assess agricultural productivity under different stresses, as in the effluents analyzed, Na+ and Cl- ions and heavy metal Hg were also found in varying proportions Parashar et al. [2], which have been studied in combination with other parameters in effluents and individually having comparative deleterious effects on crop growth essential for using effluents in proper dilutions for increasing crop productivity and abating pollution load of River Yamuna.
Interestingly it has been observed that with increasing stress seed germination is delayed as well as reduced. There was also a differential response in percentage germination and tolerance to different types of stresses with respect to crops grown. It was, therefore, proposed to screen out further and make detailed physiological and biochemical studies on the selected crops to assess their relative tolerance to the three types of environmental stresses.
Effect of different levels of treatment exposure on Germination Percentage in the two crops (Treatment x Concentration x Seedling age): The results in relation to the effect of different concentrations of the three types of environmental stresses viz., Stress I (Effluent); Stress II (Salinity); Stress III (Heavy metal) under varying concentration levels with distilled water as control on germination performance measured in terms of percent germination after 24, 48, 72, 96 and 120 hours of sowing i.e., early seedling stage, have been shown in (Table 2, Graph 2a & 2b).
Stress I (Effluent)
There was no germination at all at 24 hours in both the crops Mustard and Wheat with 100% of Effluent conc. The lowest mean germination percentage (GP) of 0.097 % was observed in the legume crop Mustard with 75% Effluent conc. at 24 hours whereas the highest mean GP (95.233%) was recorded in the cereal crop Wheat with 50% of Effluent conc. at 120 hours. In Control sets, crop Wheat showed more GP at all the durations from 24 hours - 120 hours but with 25% Effluent conc. higher GP was observed in the crop Mustard at all the durations except at 24 hours when it was a little bit lower (0.347% in Wheat and 0.323% in Mustard). With 50% Effluent conc. the GP showed a reverse trend as higher GP was observed in Wheat at all the durations except at 48 hours when it was found to be 7.734% higher in Mustard. Again with 75% and 100% Effluent conc., Mustard showed better GP than Wheat except at 24 hours with 75% Effluent conc. in Wheat when it was (0.107%) more than Mustard (0.097%).
Stress II (Salinity)
Likewise, with Salinity there was no germination at all at 24 hours in both the crops Mustard and Wheat with 16 EC of Salt conc. The lowest mean GP (0.007 %) was observed in both the crops Mustard and Wheat with 12 EC of Salt conc. at 24 hours whereas the highest mean GP (91.350%) was recorded in the cereal crop Wheat in Controls at 120 hours. In Control sets, the crop Wheat showed more GP at all the durations from 24 hours - 120 hours but with 4 EC of Salt conc. higher GP were observed in Mustard at all the durations except at 24 hours when it was a little bit lower (Wheat 0.247% and Mustard 0.243%). With 8 EC of Salt conc. GP showed a reverse trend as higher GP was observed in Mustard at all the durations except at 24 hours when it was found to be 0.01% higher in Wheat. Again with 12 and 16 EC of Salt conc. the crop Mustard showed better GP than Wheat except at 24 hours with 12 EC of Salt conc. when it happened to be similar (0.007%) in both the crops.
Stress III (Heavy metal)
As also with 100% Effluent conc. and 16 EC of Salinity conc. likewise, there was no germination at all in the two crops Mustard and Wheat with the higher Heavy metal conc. of 300 ppm at 24 hours but unlike the former treatments with the Heavy metal treatment the crops did not show any germination at 48 hours also under 300 ppm. The lowest mean GP (0.003%) was observed in both the crops at 24 hours with 200 ppm Heavy metal conc. whereas the highest mean GP (91.350%) was recorded in the cereal crop Wheat with Controls at 120 hours. In Control sets Wheat showed more GP than Mustard at all the durations from 24 hours - 120 hours but with 50, 100, 200 and 300 ppm Heavy metal conc. higher GP was observed in Mustard at all the durations except at 24 hours with 100 ppm when it was a little bit lower (0.017% in Wheat and 0.010% in Mustard) and with 200 ppm GP in both the crops showed no difference (0.003% in both Wheat and Mustard). Mustard showed better and 15.450% in Wheat). Thus, highest average GP of 95.233% GP than Wheat even at 300 ppm at 120 hours when it was nearly was observed in the crop Wheat in 50% of Effluent conc. at 120 double (3.007% in Mustard and 1.667% in Wheat) and was more hours while lowest GP of 1.000% was also observed in the crop than double at 120 hours with 200 ppm (36.150% in Mustard Wheat in 300 ppm of Heavy metal conc. at 72 hours.
C. D. for Treatment x Concentration x Seedling Age: Wheat = 1.604; Mustard = 1.736 Values in parentheses are representing % change (Loss)/ (gain +) from control
(Table 3, Graphs 3a & 3b) shows the effect of different levels of treatment concentration on GP as percent over control. Interestingly, stimulation has been observed in growth of both the crops as increased GP at moderate levels (25% and 50%) of Effluent conc. In the crop Mustard GP in 25% Effluent conc. showed a change in percent from Control at 24 hours (+29.200%), at 48 hours (+14.188%) and at 96 hours (+0.498%) respectively and in 50% Effluent conc. percent change from Control was observed to be at 24 hours (+36.000%), at 48 hours (+40.130), at 72 hours (+06.509%), at 96 hours (+01.315%) and at 120 hours (+01.017%) whereas in the crop Wheat GP only in 50% Effluent conc. Increased at 24 hours (+16.216), 72 hours (+5.813) and 120 hours (+4.250).
Besides, both the crops Mustard and Wheat did not show any seed germination at all in 100% (Effluent), 16 dsm-1 (Salinity) and 300 ppm (Heavy metal) concentrations at 24 hours and in 300 ppm (Heavy metal) conc. at 48 hours also. Further, it was observed that 75% (Effluent), 12 dsm-1 (Salinity) and 200 ppm (Heavy metal) concentrations for three types of stresses and also 72 hours of germination were found to be quite critical for the two crops (Table 4 and Graph 4a & 4b), therefore, on the basis of percent over control at 72 hours with 75% (Effluent), 12 dsm-1 (Salinity) and 200 ppm (Heavy metal) concentrations respectively the germination percentage in the two crops showed the following trend:
Effluent: Mustard [71.979%* (-28.021)], Wheat [56.588%* (-43.412)]
Salinity: Mustard [61.350%* (-38.650)], Wheat [52.173%* (-47.827)]
Heavy Metal: Mustard [23.621%* (-76.379)], Wheat [15.870%* (-84.130)]
*Values are arithmetic mean of three replicates; Values in parentheses are representing % change from control
** Significant at 1% Level of Probability
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) Table - Percent Germination (Table 5 and Graph 5a & 5b) shows that all the main effects viz., Treatment (A), Concentration (B) and Duration (C) with their interactions (A x B, A x C, B x C, A x B x C) were highly significant at 1% level of probability.
This is also evident from the (Table 2) wherein Analysis of Variance (treatment, concentration and duration), (Table 6) (treatment x concentration), (Table 7) (treatment x seedling age) and (Table 8) (concentration x seedling age) the effect of different levels of concentration exposure and seedling age on germination percentage in the two crops respectively have been depicted. The final interaction was also observed to be statistically significant.
A review of the (Table 6 & Graph 6) (treatment x except in the Controls where in Wheat it was more than that in concentration) shows that the crop Mustard had better GP than Mustard the crop Wheat in all the three types of treatment, that is, the highest mean GP in the two crops (Mustard 47.038% and Wheat 46.228%) was when sown in Effluent followed by Salinity where it was 41.157% in Mustard and 38.257% in Wheat while lowest was in Heavy Metal treatment (Mustard 25.391% and Wheat 23.415%). Regarding concentration of the treatments, highest mean GP was found in Controls (Wheat 59.726% and Mustard 52.375%) followed subsequently in Conc. 1 (25% Effluent; 4 dsm-1 Salinity; 50 ppm Heavy Metal) where in the two crops it was observed to be Mustard 43.907% and Wheat 40.891%; Conc. 2 (50% Effluent; 8 dsm-1 Salinity; 100 ppm Heavy Metal) it was observed to be Mustard 40.864% and Wheat 38.583%; Conc. 3 (75% Effluent; 12 dsm-1 Salinity; 200 ppm Heavy Metal) it was observed to be Mustard 30.828% and Wheat 24.512% and lastly in the maximum concentration i.e., Conc. 4 (100% Effluent; 16 dsm-1 Salinity; 300 ppm Heavy Metal) it was observed to be Mustard 21.337% and Wheat 16.120%. Thus, the three treatments and their five concentrations each showed better mean GP in the legume crop Mustard than the cereal crop Wheat expect in the controls where in wheatit was more than that in mustard.
Likewise, a review of the (Table 7 & Graph 7) (treatment x seedling age) shows that the crop Mustard had better GP than the crop Wheat in all the three types of treatment as shown below for the interaction of Treatment x Concentration. Regarding seedling age, highest GP was found at 120 hours (Mustard 66.061% and Wheat 58.905%) followed subsequently at 96 hours where in the two crops it was observed to be Mustard 55.368% and Wheat 53.894%; at 72 hours it was observed to be Mustard 43.686% and Wheat 42.522%; at 48 hours it was observed to be Mustard 24.069% and Wheat 24.352% and lastly at the initial duration of 24 hours it was observed to be Wheat 0.158% and Mustard 0.127%. Thus, the three treatments and five durations also showed better mean GP in the legume crop Mustard than the cereal crop Wheat except at 24 hours where in Wheat comparatively better seed sprouting took place.
Lastly, review of the (Table 8 & Graph 8) (concentration x seedling age) shows that still the crop Mustard had better GP than the crop Wheat in all the four concentrations except Controls where it happened to be more in Wheat. Regarding seedling age, as shown below Wheat had comparatively better seed germination at 24 and 48 hours whereas Mustard showed better mean GP at the increasing seedling age 72, 96 and 120 hours.
Thus, in general the GP decreased with increasing concentration levels of the three stresses, i.e., Effluent, Salinity and Heavy metal. The differential behaviour of the genotypes in relation to the three types of stresses as well as with seedling age is also evident from (Table 2) as described earlier under the interactions of the main factors. Interestingly, as shown in the (Table 3) stimulation has been observed in growth of both the crops as increased GP at moderate levels (25% and 50%) of Effluent conc. This stimulation in growth may be attributed to the nutritional supplementation at low concentration (25% and 50% in Mustard and 50% in Wheat) of salts present in the Effluents. Besides, seeing overall results Heavy metal proved to be more toxic than Effluents and Salinity stresses for seed germination at higher concentrations of 75% and 100% (Effluent), 12 and 16 dsm-1 (Salinity) and 200 and 300 ppm (Heavy metal). However, significant differences were noticed in the germination percentage (GP) of the two crops studied with the legume crop Mustard showing better performance in GP than the cereal crop Wheat in the three types of Stresses as compared to Controls.
Conclusively, it can be inferred that with increasing seedling age, seed germination increased in the two crops whereas with increase in treatment concentrations, GP was decreased except at lower concentrations in the Effluent Treatment, seed germination showed an enhancement over the Controls.
Discussion
Effluent effect on crop plants
Environment is deteriorating at very fast rate. Unplanned and unsystematic urbanization and industrialization are giving rise to serious problems of pollution. With the increasing urbanization and industrialization the disposal of sewage effluents on agricultural land is becoming a serious problem all over the world. The composition of sewage sludge changes with the type of industries discharging their effluents into the sewer system. The present age is an era of rapid industrialization which has revolutionized the human life. It has facilitated human life in many ways Khanna & Ram Babu [11]. Reuse of wastewater effluent is currently receiving more attention because of water shortages. Use of treated wastewater effluent can be a new source of water Naddafi [12]; Parashar [7]; Snehlata [5]. Traditionally, domestic wastewater was used as fertilizer in agriculture or as soil conditioner in some parts of Asia. Sewage Waste Management by Irrigating Crop plants for their sustainable improvement was projected by Sharma et al. [13] . The continuous use of industrial effluents by people in the adjoining area has become a common practice which results in accumulation of industrial pollutants and toxic metals in soil to such a level that may become phytotoxic and hazardous for the life of animal and human beings Sharma [1], Singh [14], Parashar [7], Parashar et al. [2]. The recurring inception of the effluents in soil may alter the soil surface colour and can also block the soil pores in the field. The physico-chemical analysis of soils [Electrical Conductivity, Hydrogen Ion Concentration, Sodium adsorption ratio (SAR), Residual sodium carbonate (RSC), Total Nitrogen, Total Organic Matter and Total Organic Phosphorous] irrigated with effluents from the polluted sites exhibited significantly higher values for almost all the parameters during the entire period of investigation Parshar et al. [2]. Pollution of River Yamuna at Mathura has been taken up by Sharma [6], Sharma [15], Parashar [7], Parashar et al. [16], Singh [17] studied physico-chemical investigation of industrial effluent and its effect on germination of Triticum aestivum (wheat). Physicochemical analysis of industrial effluents merging in Yamuna River at Mathura effect of irrigation with contaminated Yamuna River Water on seed germination and growth of Sorghum vulgare and Triticum aestivum L were studied by Sharma [1], Parashar et al. [18]; wheat and mustard Parashar [7]; wheat, barley, mustard and bakla Snehlata [9]. The polluted effluent water first of all affects the first step of plant life i.e., germination of seeds, by inhibiting enzyme action Sharma [1]; Parashar [7]; Snehlata [5]. Presence of heavy toxic metals in effluents caused plasmolysis in test plant Triticum aestivum Singh [14], Mishra et al. [19], Sharma [1], Parashar [7], Snehlata [5] reported that polluted water also contains beneficial elements (N, P, K) as well as toxic metals (Cr, Ni, Zn, Cd, Pb, Hg, Pb and As). Besides, increase in NH4+-N concentration in effluent due to the mineralization of easily decomposable nitrogenous substances present in the sludge resulting in the release of NH4+-N and later the decrease in the concentration of NH4+-N may be due to plant uptake and reduced rate of release of NH4+-N from sludge Singh et al. [20], fixation and volatilization losses Nagarajah [21]. The effluents along with N, P, K released higher amounts of NH4+-N. Besides, NO3--N recorded due to withholding of water and conversion of NH4+-N to NO3-- N (mineralization). The NO3-- N concentration may be due to immobilization and de-nitrification by general soil micro-flora. A higher NO3--N concentration recorded may also be caused by oxidation of NH4+-N to NO3--N in the rhizosphere, resulting due to the excess proliferation of plant roots rendering the soil more oxidative Sakai [22]; Smith & Delaune [23]. Thus, the present study revealed that the higher N content in the effluents released significantly higher N fraction in the soil through decomposition. This material can be considered as an organic manure and soil amendment if properly treated and diluted before used for irrigating crops. The addition of sludge to agricultural land has been reported to increase the yields of many plants Sharma [1]; Unnamalai et al. [24]; Snehlata [5]. In the present analysis investigation was undertaken to assess the effect of mixed effluent on water quality of industrial area of Yamuna River at Mathura and its impact on germination of the crop plants, Mustard and Wheat usually cultivated in this area. The detrimental effects of water pollution due to discharge of industrial effluents have been well documented in various crops Sharma [1]; Dalai & Mohanty [25] suggesting various degrees of dilution of effluents beneficial to the crops. The studies conducted by various workers Kadioglu & Algur [26]; Tiwarl et al. [27]; Muthukumar & Arokiasamy [28]; Subramani et al. [29]; Sharma [1]; Dalai & Mohanty [30] revealed that the lower effluent concentration stimulates the plant growth whereas inhibiting at higher concentrations as also shown in the present work. The studies conducted by Pragasam & Kannabiran [31] on Vigna mungo with distillery effluent inhibited the growth of the seedlings. A large number of reviews Kannabiran & Pragasam [32]; Kumar [33]; Chidambaram et al. [34]; Kannan [35]; Pragasam and Kannabiran [31], Pragasam & Kannabiran [36,37]; Mishra & Pandey [38]; Sharma [1] are available with regards to the effect of city and industrial effluents in the laboratory experimentation with various commonly cultivated crop plants. The effects of industrial effluent on germination of seeds were attributed to the presence of bio-toxic substances which alters the seed-water interaction necessary for triggering enzyme activity Baruah & Das [39]; Sharma [1]. Studies conducted by Kannabiran &Pragasam [32], Chidambaram et al. [34], [36,37] reported that sugar mill effluent severely affected the germination and seedling growth of various seeds which also confirms our observations. Studies on the impact of textile waste water on seed germination and growth development of Vicia faba L. and were undertaken by Sharma et al. [38]. Further studies on Impact of paper mill effluent on seed germination and seedling growth of Cyamompis tetragonoloba L and Vigna radiata Lwere also performed by Sharma et al. [39,40]. Impact of industrial effluent on seed germination and seedling growth of Citrullus vulgaris var. and impact of textile wastewater on seed germination and growth development on Lycopersicon esculentum were also studied Sharma et al. [41]. Sharma et al. [42] reported the impact of paper mill Effluent on seed germination and seedling growth of Vigna radiata L. in Sanganer Region at Jaipur (Raj) India.
Salinity effect on crop plants
Soil salinity is a matter of global concern for stepping up agricultural production. Crop growth and its productivity are hampered on such lands on account of several unfavourable soil factors Bohnert et al. [43]. Saline soils have the problem of high soluble salts Sharma et al. [44]; Sharma & Baijal [45]; Babu et al. [46] creating a condition of physiological drought which limits plant growth by inhibiting nutrient and water uptake by plants [7,47-58]. Sodium (Na+) and chloride (Cl-) are among the most common ions found in excess in saline soils and some plant species are especially sensitive to one or both of these ions [59-65]. With many species, however, the ionic composition seems to be less important than the total amount of salt. This non-specific suppression of growth by salt has been interpreted as an osmotic phenomenon Bernstein & Hayward [66]. A general suppression of growth is probably the most common plant response to salinity. Salinity suppresses plant growth. The suppression increases as the salt concentration increases [Maas and Nieman, 1978]. The depressing effect has been generally attributed to the increased soil-moisture-stress or to specific toxic effect of the ions as a result of their absorption and accumulation Bhardwaj [67]. Soil salinity adversely affects the seed germination and various crops as well as their varieties exhibit a differential behaviour at different degrees of salinity during germination. Salinity has been shown to affect the time and rate of germination, the size of plants, branching and leaf size and overall plant anatomy Poljakoff-Mayber [68]. The delayed and decreased germination has been observed by many workers in different plants. Not only that different plants exhibit a differential response to salinity during germination but also their varieties show wide differences in their salt tolerance as observed in barley, oats, wheat, alfalfa, sugar beets, corn and field peas [69-74] in barley, sugar beet, corn, kidney bean and alfalfa; Ayers et al. [75] in barley; Kim [76], in different vegetable crops; Bhardwaj & Rao [77] in gram; Mehta& Desai [78] in pearl millets, tobacco, cotton, bean, tomato, gram, cabbage and pea; Dewey [1960] in Agropyron sp.; Bernstein [79] in various fruit crops during germination and seedling stage; Wahhab [1961] in wheat, paddy, maize and barley; [80-86] in various leguminous crops; Maliwal [87], in maize; in rice Pearson et al. [88]; bajra Abichandani & Bhatt [89]; in sorghum Abichandani & Bhatt [89]; Maliwal [87]; Ogra & Baijal [80], Nauhbar [55]; Yadav [54]; on wheat, Nauhbar [55]; in legumes. In general, it seems that germination or seedling stage is the most sensitive stage to saline water. Some varieties are more tolerant at germination as compared to others and the varietal differences are so wide that some varieties may fail to give good germination even at an EC of 4 dsm-1 of water whereas the others may do well up to 20 dsm-1 Gupta [18]. It is usual that with increasing salinity, germination is delayed as well as reduced. There is also differential response in percentage of germination with respect to varieties. The reduction in germination under saline conditions could be due to increased osmotic pressure of the soil solution. Consequently the absorption rate diminishes causing moisture stress in the seed. It could also be due to the influx of ions in quantities large enough to make them toxic to the seed embryo.
Heavy metal effect on crop plants
Mercury is a widely distributed environmental pollutant, able to induce toxicity in living organisms, including higher plants. It is an environmental pollutant which is mainly supplied via anthropogenic sources to the soil. It is harmful because of its toxicity, mobility, bioaccumulation, methylation process and transport in the atmosphere Parashar [7]; Saraswata [4]; Singh [14] ; Gautam [57]; Rodriguez et al. [82]. It is one of the best known toxic metals discharged from human activities. The global rise in mercury pollution by anthropogenic activities may have risen by three to four folds in this century, but the seriousness of the problem at local levels is many times greater. The environmental protection agencies have expressed increasing concern over the release of mercury to the environment in the past couple of years Jamal et al. [83]. Mercury pollution of the environment and its impact on crop plants has been studied by Parashar et al. [16]. There are studies about the response of crop species to heavy metals reporting mechanisms that are responsible for their tolerance or sensitivity Shriapanahi & Anderson [90]; Ernest [85]; Hall [86]; Watanabe & Osaki [87]; Mahmood et al. [88]; Vitorella et al. [89]. Mercuric chloride (HgCl2) is dominant among all mercury forms. Shriapanahi and Anderson [1986] found elevated levels of cadmium, lead and mercury in the upper layer of soil following long term application of municipal wastewater which resulted in the accumulation of toxic levels of these metals in the vegetables grown in these areas. The toxic effect of mercury on germination, growth and yield has been studied on different plants Parashar [7]; Mukherjee and De [34]; Saraswata et al. [50]; Saraswata [51]; Gautam [71]; Jamal et al. [83]; Singh [86]; Vizarova et al. [91]; Varshneya [92] have studied the phytotoxicity of heavy metal mercury on germination and early seedling growth in wheat. Our results showed that seed germination of both the crops was enhanced at all the concentrations of mercury as compared to unrteated control. Mercury treatment could break the seed dormancy and enable seeds to germinate Jamal et al. [83]. Excessive mercury ions in soil also decreased metabolic contents of seedlings in various crop plants Vizarova et al. [91]. Kaslimuthu & Subramanian [92] found reduction in seed germination. Results of the present study clearly indicate reduced germination in the two crops in response to treatments with increasing concentrations of heavy metal HgCl2. Although mercury showed sharp decline in germination performance, data presented here also show significant decrease in germination under the influence of high concentration of mercury with respect to time in the two crops which concomitant decrease in seedling vigor (observed in terms root and shoot length) indicated that the metabolic system of the seed could be modified by a very small concentration of mercury. Previous workers have speculated direct effect of heavy metals on various biomolecules decreased hydrolysis of endospermic food reserves, inhibition of various hydrolytic enzymes Parashar [5]; Singh [13]; Gautam [80]. Therefore, the set pattern of decreases in tolerance with mercury was observed as: Wheat > Mustard. Seeds treated with Hg showed lower germination percentage. Several workers Parashar [5]; Singh [13]; Gautam [80] reported that inhibition in seed germination at higher concentration of heavy metals was mainly caused by ion toxicity. Ion toxicity is associated to changes in cellular permeability, inhibition of protein activity and/or direct toxicity to the embryo and seedling Parashar [5]; Singh [13]; Gautam [80]. Reduction in germination of seeds in presence of Hg has been reported in rice [Mukherjee and Mitra, 1976] and also in other plants Parashar [5]; Singh [13]; Gautam [80]. Results also showed that mustard crop was more tolerant for heavy metal Hg in comparison to other crop wheat [93-100]. The heavy metal's accumulation in the shoot may also lead to increased phenolic compounds that may be responsible for inhibition of germination. These observations clearly show that the crop mustard suffered lesser than the other crop wheat i.e., the former crop is more tolerant than the later crop., therefore on the basis of their relative tolerance the two crops tested can be placed in the descending order of their heavy metal tolerance as follows: Mustard > Wheat [100-106].
Concluding Remarks
The aim ofthis research is to investigate comparative effects of Effluents, Salinity and Heavy metal stresses on seed germination in the two important crops wheat and mustard commonly cultivated in Mathura region Uttar Pradesh, India. The effects of three environmental stresses were tested at germination stage of these crops as this is the key event for the establishment of plants under any prevailing environmental conditions. In general, the germination percentage with increasing concentration levels of the three stresses, i.e., Effluent, Salinity and Heavy metal showing differential behavior of the two genotypes in relation to the three types of stresses as well as with seedling age. Interestingly, stimulation has been observed in growth of both the crops as increased germination percentage at moderate levels of Effluent concentration. This stimulation in growth may be attributed to the nutritional supplementation at lower concentration of salts present in the Effluents. Besides, seeing overall results Heavy metal proved to be more toxic than Effluents and Salinity stresses for seed germination at higher concentrations of 75% and 100% (Effluent), 12 and 16 dsm-1 (Salinity) and 200 and 300 ppm (Heavy metal). However, significant differences were noticed in the germination percentage of the two crops studied with the legume crop Mustard showing better growth performance than the cereal crop Wheat in the three types of Stresses as compared to Controls. The higher level of heavy metal Hg caused complete inhibition of seed germination. Therefore, Mustard crop was found to be more tolerant than Wheat crop for effluents, salinity as well as heavy metals. Thus, identification of plant species which can resist and clean-up metals from soils is required to improve phyto-remediation technologies. Moreover, plants have been proposed as bio-monitors of soil contamination but also as biomarkers of the environmental risk of pollutants.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Principal and Head Departments of Botany and Chemistry K.R. College, Mathura for kindly permitting and helping to work for the present investigation.
References
- Sharma, Ajeet Kumar (2004) Water quality problem In Mathura and Its effect on the physiology of major crops In the region. Dr BR Ambedkar University, Agra, India.
- Parashar, Nidhi Sharma, Ajit Kumar Sharma, Goswami AK, Ravi Sharma (2016) City and Industrial effluent analysis at five selected sites In Mathura District UP India. Advances in Plants and Agriculture Research (communicated).
- Pathak, Abha (2016) Differential Growth and Metabolic Behaviour of Cereal and Legume Crops Under the Influence of Heavy Metal Cadmium. Dr BR Ambedkar University, Agra, India.
- Saraswat, Kapila (2016) Studies on the Phyto-toxicity of Heavy Metal Mercury on Germination, Early Seedling Growth and Biochemical Changes in Wheat (^^^ ^). Dr BR Ambedkar University, Agra, India.
- Snehlata (2016) Utilization of Sewage Effluents for Irrigating Crop Plants for Their Sustainable Improvement with special Reference to Mathura. Dr BR Ambedkar University, Agra, India.
- Sharma, Ravi (1976) Environmental Problems in Mathura; Workshop on Environmental Education for Asian Youth. Proc Indian Environmental Society 56: 1
- Parashar, Nidhi (2011) Planning and Investigation for City and Industrial Effluent Utilization in Abating Pollution of River Yamuna and Improving Agricultural Production. Dr BR Ambedkar University, Agra, India.
- Garrard A (1945) The effect of b-indolyl acetic acid on the germination and root growth of certain members of Cruciferae. New Phytol 53(2): 165-176.
- Sarin MN, Rao IM (1956) Effect of sodium sulphate on early seedling growth of gram and wheat. Agra Univ J Res Sci 5(1): 143-154.
- Sharma (1982) Physiology of plant tolerance to salinity at early seedling stage. Agra, India.
- Khanna P, Ram Babu P (1997) Environmental evaluation of economic growth: An agenda for change. Indian Textile Jour 107(11): 4-18.
- Naddafi K, Jaafarzadeh N, Mokhtari M, Zakizadeh B, Sakian MR (2005) Effects of wastewater stabilization pond effluent on agricultural crops. Inter Jour Environ Sc and Tech 1(4): 273-277.
- Sharma, Ravi (2016) Increasing the Productivity and Making Safe Use of Poor Quality Waste Waters in Agriculture. RBS College, Agra, India, p. 27-28.
- Singh, Shalini (2009) Relative tolerance of crop plants to heavy metal pollution. Dr B R Ambedkar Univ, Agra, India.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Ravi Sharma and Nidhi Parashar Sharma (2014) Heavy metal analysis of ground water of Sanganer Tehsil at Jaipur, Rajasthan, India. Jaipur, Rajastan, India, p. 25.
- Parashar, Nidhi Sharma, Kapila Saraswat, Abha Pathak, Snehlata, et al. (2015a) Environmental hazards- mercury pollution of the environment and its impact. KR College, Mathura, Souvenir, India, p. 32.
- Singh DK, Nidhi Parashar, Ravi Sharma (2008) Physico-chemical analysis of effluents from a carpet industry. Plant Archives 8(2): 577583.
- Parashar, Nidhi Sharma, Singh DK, Ajit Kumar Sharma, Babu D, et al.(2014) Physico-chemical analysis of industrial effluents merging in Yamuna River at Mathura effect of irrigation with contaminated Yamuna River Water on seed germination and growth of Sorghum vulgare and Triticum aestivum L National Seminar on Yamuna Water Pollution and its Control Measures, Agra UP, India, p. 43.
- Mishra SG, Tiwari SD, Mani D (1998) Relevance of sewage sludge in agriculture in 21st Century. Vijana Parishad Anussandhan Patrika 41(4).
- Singh M, Lal P (1972) Salt tolerance of seeds of black gram (Phaseolus mungo) during germination stage. Indian J Agric Sci 42: 135-139.
- Nagarajah S (1988) In: Green Manure in Rice Farming, IRRI, Philippines, pp. 193.
- Sakai H (1970) A method for determining nitrifying power of paddy soil and some results with its use. Progress Report of the All India Coordinated Rice Improvement Project 2, Kharif, India, pp. 195.
- Smith CJ, Delaune RD (1984) Effect of rice plants on nitrification, denitrification loss of nitrogen under green house conditions. Plant and Soil 79(2): 287-290.
- Unnamalai CT, Ganapathy M, Baradhan G, Ramesh N (2007) Studies on the biofunctional efficiency of industrial and urban solid wastes on rice production based on their mineralization. Plant Archives 7(2): 705707.
- Dalai B, Mohanty BK (2008) Ecophysiological studies on sugar mill effluents on the seedling morphology and biochemistry of Pisum sativum L. Plant Archives 8(1): 155-158.
- Kadioglu A, Algur OF (1990) The effect of vinasse on the growth of Helianthus annus and Pisum sativum Part 1. The effects on some enzymes and chlorophyll and protein contents. Environ Pollut 67(3): 223-232.
- Tiwari P, Elcey DD, Bhatia (1993) Responses of two cultivars of Indian mustard [Brassica juncea (L) Zern & Coss] to distillery. Jour Environ & Pollut 3(3&4): 131-143.
- Sharma, Ravi (2013) Screening for salt tolerance - Selection of salt tolerant and salt sensitive wheat cultivars. Delhi at CSIR National Physical Laboratory and IARI, New Delhi, India, pp. 270.
- Muthukumar B, Arokiasamy DI (1994) Effects of distillery waste on the nitrate reduction system in Vigna mungo (Black gram). J Ecotoxicol Environ Monitoring 4: 27-33.
- Subramani A, Sundarmoorthy P, Lakshmanachary AS (1995) Effect of distillery effluent on growth yield and productivity of Vigna radiate. Poll Res 141: 477-482.
- Pragasam A, Kannabiran B (2001a) Effect of distillery effluent on the morphology, biochemistry and yields of Vigna mungo. Adv Plant Sci 14(2): 547-552.
- Kannabiran B, Pragasam A (1993) Effects of distillery effluents on seed germination, seedlings growth and pigment content of Vigna mungo (L) Hepper (CVT 9). Geobios 20: 108-112.
- Kumar, Rajesh (1995) Effect of sugar mill effluent on the seed germination and seedling growth of Cicer arietinum CV No. 58. Adv Plant Sci 8(1): 25-26.
- Chidambaram, Pillai S, Pugazhendi Z, Lakshmana C, Shama, et al. (1996) Effect of chemical industry waste on germination, growth and some biochemical prameters ofVigna radiata L Wilkjeck and Vigna mungo L Hepper. J Enu Poll 3(3&4): 131-134.
- Kannan J (2001) Effect of distillery effluents on crop plants. Adv Plant Sci 14(1): 127-132.
- Pragasam A, Kannabiran B (2001b) Effect of distillery effluent on the photosynthetic pigment and nitrogenous compound in Vigna mungo (L) Hepper. J Swamy Bot ci 18: 21-23.
- Pragasam A, Kannabiran B (2004) Effect of distillery effluent on the NPK contents of Vigna mungo (L) Hepper and physico-chemical properties of soil. Indian Environ and Ecoplan 8(2): 297-300.
- Mishra V, Pandey SD (2002) Effect of distillery effluent and leachates of industrial sludge on the germination of Bengal gram (Cicer arietinum). Poll Res 21(4): 461-467.
- Baruah BK, Das M (1998) Study on impact of paper mill effluent on germination behaviour and seedling growth of crop plant Oryza sativa LPoll Res 17(1): 65-68.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Ravi Sharma (2014a) Impact of textile waste water on seed germination and growth development of Vicia faba L. at Jaipur, Rajasthan, India. Journal of the Kalash Science 2(2): 47-51.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Ravi Sharma (2014b) Impact of paper mill effluent on seed germination and seedling growth of Cyamompis tetragonoloba L in Sanganer Region of Jaipur, Rajastan, India. Jour Environ Sc Computer Sc and Engineer^ Tech (JECET) 3(4): 1830-1835.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Ravi Sharma (2014c) Impact of paper mill effluent on seed germination and seedling growth of Vigna radiata L. A case study in Sanganer Region at Jaipur, Rajasthan, India, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, UK, 20: 1-5.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Ravi Sharma (2015b) Impact of textile wastewater on seed germination and growth development on Lycopersicon esculentum at Jaipur, Rajasthan, India. Agra UP, India, p. 25.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Ravi Sharma (2016) Impact of Paper Mill Effluent on Seed Germination and Seedling Growth of Vigna radiata L.A Case Study in Sanganer Region at Jaipur, Rajasthan, India. India, pp. 209-215
- Bohnert HJ, Nelson DE, Jensen RG (1995) Adaptation to environmental stresses. The Plant Cell 7: 1099-1111.
- Sharma, Ravi BD, Baijal, Goyal AK (1981) Salinity - an increasing environmental hazard. Proc Indian Environmental Society115: 116117.
- Sharma, Ravi, Baijal BD (1987) The problem of saline wastelands and their management - a biological approach. K.R. College, Mathura, India, p. 21.
- Babu, Dinesh DK Singh SK, Sharma Arti, Ravi Sharma (2011) The problem of saline wastelands and their management - a biological approach. Biochemistry and Pharmacology 8(6): 274.
- Greenway H, Munns R (1980) Mechanisms of salt tolerance in nonhalophytes. Annual Review of Plant Physiology 31: 1-678.
- Sharma, Ravi (1987) towards an understanding of the physiology of salt tolerance in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) at early seedling stage. 22a-8: 32.
- Sharma, Ravi (2012) Strategy for sustainable improvement of selected crops-production under saline conditions emphasizing biocontrol of salinity. Mangalayatan University, Aligarh, Souvenir and Abstract Book, Technical Session 11, OP-013: 60.
- Sharma, Ravi (2015) Genotypic response to salt stress: 1 - Relative tolerance of certain wheat cultivars to salinity. Adv Crop Sci Tech 3(4): 1000192.
- Sharma, Ravi (2017) Genotypic response to salt stress: 1 1 - Pattern of Differential Relative Behaviour of Salt-tolerant, Moderatelt-Tolerant and Salt-Sensitive Wheat cultivars under Salt Stressed Conditions. International Jour of Ground Sediment & Water 05: 205- 216.
- Yadav, Neetu (2006) Physiology of salt tolerance for effective biological control of salinity. Dr BR Ambedkar Univ, Agra, India.
- Naubhar, Suman (2005) Relative tolerance of crop plants to salt stress at the early seedling stage. Dr. BR Ambedkar Univ, Agra, India.
- Rani S, Sharma SK, Ravi Sharma (2009) Germination and early seedling growth in six leguminous pulse crops under salt stress. Plant Archives 9(1): 145-151.
- Gautam, Shelja (2010) Study of phytotoxicity of heavy metal pollution and its control. Dr BR Ambedkar Univ, Agra, India.
- Bernstein L, Hayward HE (1958) Physiology of salt tolerance. Annual Review of Plant Physiology 9: 1-48.
- Bhardwaj SN (1959) Influence of NaCl and Na2CO3 on some aspects of carbohydrate metabolism in wheat. Mem Indian bot soc 2: 75-78.
- Poljakoff-Mayber A (1975) Morphological and anatomical changes in plants as a response to salinity stress. 1n: Poljakoff-Mayber A, Gale J (Eds.), Plants in Saline Environment Ecological studies. Springer- Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, pp. 97-117.
- Harris FS (1915) Effect of alkali salts in soil on germination and growth of crops. J Agr Res 5: 1-53.
- Shive J W (1916) The effect of salt concentration on seeds. Expt Sta 37th Ann Rept, USA, pp. 455-457.
- Rudolfs W (1925) Influence of water and salt solution upon absorption and germination of seeds. Soil Sci 20(1): 15-37.
- Mulwani BT, Pollard AG (1939) Effects of alkali salts on germination of seeds. Agric Live-stk India 9: 548-555.
- Uhvits R (1946) Effects of osmotic pressure on water absorption and germination of alfalfa seeds. Amer J Bot 33(4): 278-286.
- Ayers AD, Hayward HE (1948) A method for measuring the effects of soil salinity on germination with observations on several crop plants. Amer Proc Soil Sci 13: 224-226.
- Ayers AD, Brown JW , Wadleigh CH (1952) Salt tolerance of barley and wheat in soil plots receiving several salinization regimes. Agron J 44: 307-310.
- Kim CM (1958) Effect of saline and alkaline salts on the growth and internal components of selected vegetable plants. Physiol Plant 11: 441-450.
- Bhardwaj SN, Rao 1M (1955) Studies on the effect of chloride and sulphate of sodium on germination, growth and maturity of gram. Agra Univ J Res Sci 4 (suppl): 767-776.
- Mehta BV, Desai RS (1958) Effect of soil salinity on germination of some seeds. J Soil Water Conserv India 6: 168-176.
- Bernstein L (1965) Salt tolerance of fruit crops. USDA Agric Inform Bull No 292: 8.
- Sarin MN, Narayanan A (1968) Effects of soil salinity and growth regulators on germination and seedling metabolism of wheat. Physiol Plant 21(6): 1201-1209.
- Singh M, Lal P, Singh RS (1971) Preliminary studies on the salt tolerance of moong (Phaseolus mungo) seeds at germination stage. Ann Arid Zone 10: 255-260.
- Singh M, Lal P, Singh RS (1976) A preliminary study on the inducement of salt tolerance in guar at germination stage. Agrochemica 20: 88-92.
- Uprety DC, Sarin MN (1973) Studies on salt tolerance in pea (Pisum sativum L) I. Germination and seedling growth. Indian J Agron 18: 302305.
- Uprety DC, Sarin MN (1975) Physiological studies on salt tolerance in Pisum sativum L11. Mechanism of salt action during germination. Acta Agronomica Acad Sci 24: 188-191.
- Maliwal GL (1967) Salt tolerance studies of some varieties of jowar, mung and tobacco at germination stage. 1ndian J Plant Physiol 10: 95 104.
- Pearson GA, Ayers AD, Eberhard DL (1966) Relative salt tolerance of rice during germination and early seedling development. Soil Sci 102: 151-156.
- Abhichandani C T, Bhatt P N (1965) Salt tolerance at germination of bajra (Pennisetum typhoideum) and jowar (Sorghum vulgare) varieties. Ann Arid Zone 4: 36-42.
- Ogra RK, Baijal BD (1978) Relative tolerance of some sorghum varieties to salt stress at early seedling stage. Indian J Agric Sci 48(12): 713-717.
- Gupta 1C (1979) Use of Saline Water in Agriculture - in Arid and Semi- arid Zones of India. Oxford and 1BH publishing Co, New Delhi, India.
- Rodriguez L, F Lopez-Bellido, Carnicer A, Alcalde V (2003) Phytoremediation of mercury-polluted soils using crop plants Fresen. Environ Bull 12: 967-971.
- Jamal, Shagufta Naz, Zafar Iqbal M, Mohammad Athar (2006) Evaluation of two wheat varieties for phytotoxic effect of mercury on seed germination and seedling growth. Agric conspec sci 71(2): 41-44.
- Shriapanahi M, Anderson AC (1986) Accumulation of Cd, Hg, Pb by vegetables following long-term land application of wastewater. Sci. Total Environm 52: 41-48.
- Ernest WHO (1996) Phytotoxicity of heavy metals. 1n: Rodrigues- Barrueco C (Ed.), Fertilizers and Environments, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordechet, The Netherlands, pp. 423-430.
- Hall JL (2000) Cellular mechanisms for heavy metal detoxification and tolerance. J Exp Bot 53(366): 1-11.
- Watanabe T, Osaki M (2002) Mechanisms of adaptation to high aluminum condition in native plant species growing in acid soils: A review. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal 33(7-8): 1247-1260.
- Mahmood SA, Hussain Z, Saeed, Athar M (2005) Germination and seedling growth of corn (Zea mays L.) under varying levels of copper and zinc. 1nt J Environ Sci Technol 2: 269-274.
- Vitorella VA, Capaldi FR, Stefanuto VA (2005) Recent advances in aluminum toxicity and resistance in higher plants. Braz J Plant Physiol 17: 129-143.
- Vizarova GT, Zatkalikova, Zelenakoua E (1985) Effects of Hg on some physiological processes in barley. Biologia (Bratislava) 50: 573-576.
- Gautam, Aruna (2009) The problem of saline wastelands and their management - A Biological Approach with special reference to Mathura. Dr B R Ambedkar Univ, Agra, India.
- Kaslimuthu K, Subramanian S (1990) Physiological effects of heavy metals on Zea mays (maize) seedlings. Indian J Plant Physiol 33(3): 242-244.
- Mukherjee AK, De B (1996) Hg induced metabolic changes in seedlings of cultivated cells of tomato. Geobios 23: 83-88.
- Nieman RH (1962) Some effects of NaCl on growth, photosynthesis and respiration of twelve crop plants. Bot Gaz 123(4): 279-285.
- Parashar, Nidhi Sharma, Kapila Saraswat, Abha Pathak, Snehlata, et al. (2015b) Environmental hazards- Pollution of River Yamuna at Mathura. KR College, Mathura, Souvenir, India, p. 34.
- Saroj R (2007) Investigation on salt tolerance parameters specially growth and biochemical traits for selection of salt tolerant lines in legumes at the early seedling stage. Dr B R Ambedkar University, Agra, India.
- Saroj R, Sharma SK, Ravi Sharma (2008) Effect of salinity on germination and early seedling growth in six leguminous pulse crops. Abst & Souvenir S7 (27): 156.
- Saraswat, Kapila, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Abha Pathak, Snehlata, et al.(2015) Environmental hazards- phytotoxicity of heavy metal mercury on germination and early seedling growth in wheat. KR College, Mathura, India, p. 33.
- Sharma, Ajit Kumar, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Ravi Sharma (2015a) Impact of industrial effluent on seed germination and seedling growth of Citrullus vulgaris var in Sanganer Region at Jaipur, Rajasthan, India: A case study. Agra UP, India, p. 20.
- Sharma, Ravi, Snehlata, Nidhi Parashar Sharma, Jagendra Singh, et al. (2016) Sewage Waste Management by Irrigating Crop Plants for Their Sustainable Improvement. RBS College, Agra, India, p. 27-28.
- Singh DK (2003) Effect of heavy metal on productivity of grassland. Banaras Hindu Univ, Varanasi, India.
- Singh, Shankar Pratap (2008) Physico-chemica l investigation of industrial effluent and its effect on germination of Triticum aestivum (wheat). Plant archives 8(2): 857-858.
- Singh, Yadvinder, Bijay Singh, Khind CS (1992) Nutrient transformations in soils amended with green manures. Adv Soil Sci 20: 237.
- Uprety DC, Sarin MN (1974) Physiological studies on salt tolerance in Pisum sativum L, I. Germination and seedling growth. Acta Agronomica Acad Sci 23: 269-274.
- Varshneya AK (1991) Phytotoxic effects of mercuric acetate on the development of chlorophyll in excised cotyledons of two cucurbits. Geobios 18(2-3): 119-124.
- Wahhab A (1961) Salt tolerance of various varieties of agricultural crops at the germination stage, Salinity Problems in Arid Zone. Proc Tehran Symp UNESCO 185.