Length-Weight Relationships and Condition Factor of Six Sole Fish species from Coastal Waters of Pakistan
Wajid Ali1,2, Mohammad Shafi1* and Noor Us Saher2
1Lasbella University of Agriculture, Water and Marine Sciences, Pakistan
2Centre of Excellence in Marine Biology, University of Karachi, Pakistan
Submission:June 26, 2021; Published:September 03, 2021
*Correspondence author: Mohammad Shafi, Lasbella University of Agriculture, Water and Marine Sciences, Uthal, Balochistan, Pakistan
How to cite this article: Wajid Ali, Mohammad Shafi, Noor Us Saher. Length-Weight Relationships and Condition Factor of Six Sole Fish species from Coastal Waters of Pakistan. Oceanogr Fish Open Access J. 2021; 14(2): 555884. DOI: 10.19080/OFOAJ.2021.14.555884
Abstract
The current study aimed to investigate the morphometric analysis based on length and weight relationships and condition factors of six sole fish species i.e., Cynoglossus punticeps, C. arel, C. quadrilineatus, Pseudorhombus javanicus, P. elevates, and Euryglossa orientalis belong to three different families Paralichthyidae, Cynoglossidae and Soleidae. Their feeding practices are quite different from other species as they forage mostly on bottom invertebrates, therefore, these species inhabiting in shallow muddy and sandy bottom of the continental shelf along the coast. Sole fish species were collected from five harbors i.e., Karachi fish harbor (KAH), Keti Bandar fish harbor (KBH), Korangi fish harbor (KOH), Ormara fish harbor (OFH) and Pasni fish harbor (PFH) along the coast. The significant variations were observed in morphometric parameters according to fish species. The highest condition factor was evaluated for E. orientalis (1.943) and lowest was examined for C. arel (0.469). This is the preliminary analysis from Pakistani waters and an addition of some basic information on the biology and growth of sole fish in the marine environment of Pakistan.
Keywords: Length-weight relationship; Fish assemblage; Sole fishes; Pakistan
Introduction
Length-weight relationship has a conspicuous importance to differentiate the biological stock demonstration, to understand by body condition records, figure biomass dependent on length recurrence circulations and for acoustic overviews [1-3]. Inspite of its significance and the way that these relationships are effectively acquired, they are normally absent for a few animal types, particularly those that are not economically important [3]. The relationship between length and weight is analyzed on the basis as used to explore information regarding fish condition, factors and examine the nature of the growth of fish, whether isometric or allometric [4,5]. Generally morphometric data likewise interlink between total length and total weight are essential, especially for Eco morphological studies [6,7].
An indispensable job is played by fish in the advancement of a country in spite of the fact that it is the least expensive wellspring of over-the-top nutritive protein. It has other fundamental supplements which are required to human body [8-10]. Length-weight relationship (LWR) is basic instrument in the executives of fishery it is additionally essential in fisheries the board for relative development ponders it gives vital data on the oceanic natural surroundings numerous devices were utilized in fishery science to separate fish populace, for example, hereditary and morphometric it is broadly used to realize the distinction between fish populace [11-15].
Flat fishes play a vital role in energy pathway, and it is also beneficial for conservation of benthic organisms in a form suitable for human consumption [16]. Since 1930, the relationship between Length-weight was used [17]. It was described with Cubic parabola first. W=aL3 after this procedure, it has been superseded by general parabola. The result of general parabola is much better than cubic parabola W=aLb b=2to4 to values will exist a and b they both differ between species, through annual spawning seasons [18]. When b is equal to 3 it means the growth is isometric if it is more than 3 or less than it is termed as allometric growth, thus length-weight relationship (LWR) measurement of any species prerequisite to the study about its population [19].
Fishes impart benefits to human being in plenty ways. It is also essential dietary animal basic protein source in human food [20]. The population of humans has been increasing day by day and it is inversely proportional to animal protein. The fish meat provides energy and high quality of proteins, which holds all mandatory amino acid in effortlessly digestible; thus, they are worthwhile nutritious sources [21]. The morphometric analysis can also provide the valuable information on aquatic habitat [13]. Differences appeared during the morphometric analysis are important for evaluating the species variation and structure of population on behalf of recognizing stocks [22].
Length-weight relationships of fishes are important tools in fisheries science for the various studied areas i.e., estimation of standard weight of fish species in a given length assemblage [11], growth rate, age and length structures, conversion of growth in-length equations to growth-in-weight in stock assessment models, biomass from length frequency distributions. Lengthweight relationship (LWR) considered as an imperative growth index used as a sustainable management tool by fishery biologists. Morphometric relationships among the fish used to assess and determine the possible differences between the different species and stocks of the species [12,23]. Length and weight relationship plays huge role in population dynamics and fishery biologist, where plenty stock assessment models have been entail using length-parameters.
The review of literature provides few previous studies on these important species (Table 1) Sole fishes from Cynoglossidae family are commercial fish in China. Bohai Sea and in east yellow sea [24]. Owing to overfishing, wild population is being decreased and annual output less than 1 ton now [25]. In china sole fishes are commercial fish and also culture able and these are being culture in European countries. These species are reported from both coasts of Pakistan, i.e., Makran coast and Lasbela coast including, Gwadar, jeewani, Ganz, Sur Bandar, Pasni, Ormara, Korangi and Keti Bandar. The present study intended to investigate the morphometric analysis, length-weight relationships, and condition factors of six sole fishes i.e., Cynoglossus punticeps, C. arel, C. quadrilineatus, Pseudorhombus javanicus, P. elevates and Euryglossa orientalis belong to the three families Paralichthyidae, Cynoglossidae, and Soleidae from coastal waters of Pakistan.
Materials and Methods
Flat fish sampling was conducted during a whole year of 2018 from five harbors, i.e., Karachi fish harbor (KAH), Keti Bandar fish harbor (KBH), Korangi fish harbor (KOH), Ormara fish harbor (OFH) and Pasni fish harbor (PFH) along the coast of Pakistan (Figure 1)). Fish individuals were identified up to the species level with the help of the fish identification key [26]. A total of 1238 specimens of six species (Cynoglossus punticeps, N=75; C. arel, N=216; C. quadrilineatus, N=519; Pseudorhombus javanicus, N=213; P. elevates, N=57; and Euryglossa orientalis, N=156) were used in morphometric analysis. Total length (TL) and total width (TW) measured by a stainless scale (nearest 0.1 cm), whereas total weight (TW) measured by using digital weight balance (nearest 0.01 g). Length-Weight, relationship was calculated by following equation given by Le-Cren (1951):
Where, W is the weight and L is length of fish individuals, “b” is the allometric growth parameter or slope, and “a” is termed as an initial growth factor (y-intercept). The condition factor (K) is a useful index for monitoring feeding intensity, age, and growth rates defined the well-being of the fish and was obtained using the following formula [27].
Statistical Analyses
Morphometric parameters of fishes were analyzed through basic descriptive statistics, which include mean, standard deviation, minimum and maximum. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used to assess the variations in morphometric parameters regarding fish species and fish harbors and level of significance were accepted at 0.05 probability. Pearson’s correlation analysis (r2) was used to determine the relationship between morphometric parameters in fishes. Linear regression analysis (r2) was employed to evaluate the relationship between length and weight of the fishes.
Results and Discussion
The present study provides the Length -Weight relationship (LWR) and relative condition factor (k) of total of six flatfish species (Cynoglossus punticeps, C. arel, C. quadrilineatus, Pseudorhombus javanicus, P. elevates, and Euryglossa orientalis) from three families (Figure 2), namely Cynoglossidae, Paralichthyidae, and Soleidae. were collected in the current study along the coastal waters of Pakistan. The inter and intra specific variations were observed in the length and weight relationship of studied species of flat fishes in morphometric parameters (Table 2). The morphometric parameters showed significant variations (p <0.001) among the species collected from coastal waters of Pakistan. The total mean length (cm) for all the six studied fishes was significantly varied Whereas, the highest width (cm) was observed for P. javnicus (14.09) followed by P. elevates (12.85), E. orientalis (10.36), C. puncticeps (9.77), C. qudrilineatus (9.48) and C. arel (7.17). The wet weight (g) of studied fishes ranged from 301.6 to 120.5, which was observed highest for P. elevatus and lowest for C. arel (Figure 3).
C. quadrilineatus found in abundance from all six species along the Pakistan coast. Among the sole fishes, Cynoglossus is genus of flatfish, belong to Cynglossidae family and can be distinguished by the presence of hook-on snout which is overhanging the mouth. In the current study, the “b” values were observed 2.859 as compared to the reported values (3.213) from the same fish of the family [28]. The second most abundant species P. javanicus, which was also collected from all fish harbors like C. quadrilineatus. The significant correlation (R2 = 0.83) evaluated between length-weight relationship. A positive allometry (Figure 4) was observed with the “b” values (3.043) for P. javanicus, is comparable to the reported values 3.207 for the same species [29]. Cynoglossus arel was the third most abundant species showed the significant correlation (R2 = 0.68) between length-weight relationship with a positive allometry (Figure 4).
In the current study, the observed “b” values (2.859) for C. arel can be compared with the previous reported 2.923 values [30]. Pseudorhombus elevates belongs to the Paralicthidae family, which is recognized as having 67-74 rays, anal fin with 52-58 rays by its strongly ovoid body with dorsal fin. The specimen of P. elevates only procured from Karachi fish harbor along the Sindh coast. The average length, width and wet weight of fish is 29.81 cm, 12.85 cm and 301.6 g, respectively (Table 2). The positive allometry and significant correlation (R2 = 0.73) evaluated between length-weight relationship (Figure 4). In the current study, the “b” values were observed 1.019 as compared to the reported values3.290 [28]. The average length, width, and wet weight of C. puncticeps ranged from 30.11 to 32.44 cm, 9.46 to 10.13 cm and 138 to 204 g, respectively (Table 2).
The significant correlation (R2 = 0.49) evaluated between the length-weight relationship of C. puncticeps and showed isometric allometry (Figure 4). In the current study, the observed “b” values were less 2.02 as compared to the reported values 3.12 [31]. Total 156 individuals of E. orientalis were collected from two harbors i.e., Keti Bunder and Karachi fish harbors. The significant correlation (R2 = 0.76) evaluated between length-weight relationship and showed a positive allometry (Figure 4). In the current study, the “b” values were observed 2.94 as compared to the reported values 2.927 [32]. E. orientalis belongs to Soleidae family; it is a marine fish species. It populates in shallow muddy and sandy extremities of coastal waters and also in brackish water. It feeds on base enduring invertebrates, mainly small crustaceans [33].
The length-weight relationships presented the significant positive correlation for C. quadrilineatus (r2= 0.75), C. arel (r2=0.68), P. javanicus (r2=0.83), however, C. puncticeps (r2=49) showed slight negative correlation. The variations in morphometric parameters among the species most likely due to the ecological conditions of the niche and/or physiological condition of fish [20]. However, some scientists already recognized the factors affect the distribution and profusion of fish such as spawning rates, supply of food and depth of water, vegetation, breeding grounds and some other factors which have been recommended as major factors and the abundance of numerous families in Lake of Kianji [34].
The results of this study provide useful basic biological information about the most conspicuous species of fish caught in the study area that can also be compared to surrounding areas, The Fulton’s condition factor (K) is an extent as linking the length and weight for a particular fish, therefore it could be influenced by the same factors as Length and weight relationship. It was proposed that if the K value is 1.00, the condition of the fish is poor, long, and thin. A 1.20 value of K indicates that the fish is of modest condition and acceptable to numerous anglers [35]. If the fish would have a K value that is approximately 1.40 or more considered as a good and well-proportioned. The condition factor (K) for the studied species ranged from 0.406 to 1.94 (Table 3), the lowest condition factor was evaluated for C. arel that showed the less favorable environmental condition of the area for this species. Similar condition factor was described from coastal waters of Nigeria in Lagos state [36].
The higher condition factor evaluated for E. orientalis at Korangi fish harbor, which showed the favorable environmental condition in the area. Similar condition factor was described from coastal waters of Parangipettai Coast, India [37]. The condition factor (K) of C. puncticeps and C. quardilineatus was 0.735 and 0.634 respectively (Table 3), showed the moderate favorable environmental condition in the area. Similar condition factor for these species were described from coastal waters of Nigeria from Nkoro River Niger Delta [38]. For the C. arel the K value (0.469) showed the poor conditions and similar condition factor was described from coastal waters of Tighra reservoir, Gwalior, throughout May 2012 to April 2013. Tighra reservoir mendacities on 26-12’0” latitude and 78 - 30” E Longitude [39]. The condition factor (K) for P. elevatus calculated as 1.138 (Table 3), which showed the favorable environmental condition in the area. Similar condition factor was described from coastal waters of Iran muddy shores of the inter-tidal zone of Bandar Abbas city, Persian Gulf, Iran [40]. The highest (1.927) condition factor (K) was observed for E. orientalis (Table 3), which showed the favorable environmental condition in the area.
Based on this criterion, the sampled fishes along the coast were in good and moderate conditions except C. arel, However the difference in condition factor could be due to the availability of food organisms at a particular time as well as the difference of development [41]. The present data could not clarify the factors among those described above could have led to these observations. Mean values of length-weight relationship and condition factor were therefore considered to be indicators of the study area regardless the sampling locations. Moreover, in present study, the factors that affect and predictors of the length-weight relationship, such as habitat, seasonal consequence, stomach richness, preservation techniques, adulthood stage, maturity, age, and gender [42,43] were not taken into consideration. Due to such reasons, the estimated length-weight relationship and the values of a and b can be considered as the mean values, as proposed by several authors [44].
The variations in morphometric parameters among the coastal areas probably due to the ecological conditions of the niche and/or physiological status of fish [20]. It is well known that the functional regression b, value varies according to the body shape of fish and some life history parameters such as maturity, maximum size, growth rate, and others factors like habitat, stomach fullness, health, sex, age, etc., [1,4,45]. The results of this study provide useful basic biological information about the most conspicuous species of fish caught in the study area that can also be compared to surrounding areas, like the Veracruz Coral Reef System National Park [45].
Conclusion
This study aimed to investigate the morphometric analysis, length-weight analysis, and condition factor of six endemic species (Cynoglossus quardilineatus, C. arel, C. puncticeps, Pseudorhombus javanicus, P. elevatus, and Euryglossa orientalis) inhabiting in the coastal waters of Pakistan. The significant variation (p <0.05) was observed in length, width, and weight among the six fish species. The length-weight analysis showed the significant positive relationship in between length and weight of all studied fishes except negative growth relationship Pseudorhombus javanicus. The mean condition factor was examined highest for E. orientalis and was lowest for C. arel that inhabiting in coastal waters of Pakistan. The current study provides the basic information on length-weight relationships and condition factor ‘K’ for six sole fish species, and it would be utilize in biology and ecology of these fishes to manage the fin fish fishery resources in coastal waters of Pakistan.
References
- Froese R (2006) Cube law, condition factor and weight–length relationships: history, meta‐analysis and recommendations. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 22(4): 241-253.
- Vaz-dos-Santos AM, Rossi-Wongtschowski CLDB (2013) Length-weight relationships of the ichthyofauna associated with the Brazilian sardine, Sardinella brasiliensis, on the Southeastern Brazilian Bight (22 S-29 S) between 2008 and 2010. Biota Neotropica 13(2): 326-330.
- Eduardo LN, Frédou T, Lira AS, Silva LVS, Ferreira BP, et al. (2019) Length–weight relationship of thirteen demersal fishes from the tropical Brazilian continental shelf. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 35(2): 590-593.
- Ricker WE (1975) Computation and interpretation of biological statistics of fish populations. Fish Res Board Canada Bull 191(1): 82.
- Ahmad F, Dewanti LP, Arnenda GL, Rizal A (2019) Length-Weight Relationship and Catch Size of Bigeye Tuna (Thunnusobesus) Landed in Benoa, Bali, Indonesia. World News of Natural Sciences 23: 34-42.
- Motta FS, Gadig OBF, Namora RC, Braga FMS (2005) Size and sex compositions, length-weight relationship, and occurrence of the Brazilian sharp nose shark, Rhizopriono donlandii, caught by artisanal fishery from southeastern Brazil. Fish Res 74: 116-126.
- Gurkan S, Taskavak E (2019) The relationships between gut length and prey preference of three pipe fish (Syngnathusacus, Syngnathustyphle, Nerophisophidion Linnaeus, 1758) species distributed in Aegean Sea, Turkey. Iran J Fish Sci 18(4): 1093-1100.
- Ayoade A A (2011) Length-weight relationship and diet of African carp Labeoogunensis (Boulenger, 1910) in Asejire Lake Southwestern Nigeria. J fisheries Aquatic Sci 6(4): 472-478.
- Bolarinwa J B, Popoola Q (2013) Length-weight relationship and condition factors of six economic fishes of Ibeshe water side, Lagos Lagoon, Nigeria. Proceedings of the international conference on Oceanography, Orlando-Florida, U.S.A.
- Balogun AM (2015) The Fisheries subsector in a Declining Oil-based Economy; Paradigm shift for Economic Diversification and Employment Generation. Keynote address delivered at The 30th annual conference of Fisheries Society of Nigeria, Asaba, Nigeria.
- Sinovcic G, Franicevic M, Zorica B, Ĉikes‐Keĉ V (2004) Length–weight and length–length relationships for 10 pelagic fish species from the Adriatic Sea (Croatia). Journal of Applied Ichthyology 20(2): 156-158.
- Mendes B, Fonseca P, Campos A (2004) Weight–length relationships for 46 fish species of the Portuguese west coast. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 20(5): 355-361.
- Pauly D (1993) Fish byte section. Editorial. Naga. ICLARM Quart, 16, 26.
- Mir J I, Sarkar U K, Dwivedi A K, Gusain O P, Jena J K (2013) Stock structure analysis of Labeo rohita (Hamilton, 1822) across the G anga basin (India) using a truss network system. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 29(5): 1097-1103.
- Cheng Q Q, Lu D R, Ma L (2005) Morphological differences between close populations discernible by multivariate analysis: a case study of genus Coilia (Teleostei: Clupeiforms). Aquatic Living Resources 18(2): 187-192.
- De Groot S J (1971) On the interrelationships between morphology of the alimentary tract, food and feeding behaviour in flatfishes (Pisces: Pleuronectiformes). Netherlands J Sea Res 5(2): 121-196.
- Bond CE (1979) Biology of Fishes. In: Saunders College Publishing, Philadelphia, Pp. 514.
- Ahemed A H (1987) Fish biology. In: University of El Basra, Iraq, Pp. 279.
- Le Cren E D (1951) The length-weight relationship and seasonal cycle in gonad weight and condition in the perch (Percafluviatilis). Journal of Animal Ecology 20(2): 201-219.
- De Grandchamp K L, Garvey J E, Csoboth L A (2007) Linking adult reproduction and larval density of invasive carp in a large river. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 136(5): 1327-1334.
- Weatherley AH, Gill HS (1998) The biology of fish growth. In: Academic Press, New York, Pp. 442.
- Turan C, Erguden D, Turan F, Gurlek M (2004) Genetic and morphologic structure of Liza Abu (Heckel, 1843) populations from the Rivers Orontes, Euphrates and Tigris. Turk J Vet Anim Sci 28: 729-734.
- King R P (1996) Length-weight relationships of Nigerian coastal water fishes. Naga, The ICLARM Quarterly 19(4): 53-58.
- Masuda H, Amaoka K, Araga C, Uyeno T, Yoshino T (1984) The fishes of the Japanese archipelago. In: Tokai University Press, Tokyo, Japan, P. 456.
- Jiang YW, Wan RJ (2005) Tongue sole (Cynoglossussemilaevis) culture techniques. pp. 663-665. In: J L Lei (ed.). Marine Fish Culture Theory and Techniques. China Agricultural Press, Beijing, Pp. 1002.
- Bianchi G (1985) FAO species identification sheets for fishery purposes. Field guide to the commercial marine and brackish-water species of Pakistan. Prepared with the support of PAK/77/033 and FAO (FIRM) Regular Programme. Rome: FAO. pp 1- 200.
- Fulton TW (1904) The rate of growth of fishes. 22nd Annual Report of the Fishery Board of Scotland 3: 141-241.
- Aghajanpour M, Raeisi H, Moradinasab A, Daliri M, Parsa M, et al. (2015) Length‐weight relationships of six fishes from intertidal and coastal waters in the northern Persian Gulf. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 31(2): 403-404.
- Park JM, Huh S H (2015) Length–weight relations for 29 demersal fishes caught by small otter trawl on the south-eastern coast of Korea.
- Jayaprakash AA (2001) Length weight relationship and relative condition in Cynoglossusmacrostomus Norman and C. arel (Schneider). Journal of Marine biological Association of India 43(1&2): 148-154.
- Karna SK, Sahoo DK, Seth JK, Mohapatro D, Rout AK, et al. (2018) Length–weight relationship of three Cynoglossus species (C. puncticeps, C. lingua and C. lida) from Chilika lagoon, India. Journal Applied ichthyology 34(4): 988-989.
- Awan KP, Qamar N, Farooq N, Panhwar SK (2017) Sex Ratio, Length Weight Relationships and Condition of Eight Fish Species Collected FromNarreri Lagoon, Badin, Sindh. Pakistan. Journal of Aquaculture & Marine Biology 5(4): 00130.
- Psomadakis PN, HB Osmany, M K Moazzam (2015) Field identification guide to the living marine resources of Pakistan. FAO Species Identification Guide for Fishery Purposes. Rome, FAO
- Ita EO (1978) An analysis of fish distribution in Kainji lake Nigeria. Hydrobiologia 58(3): 233-244.
- Barnham C, Baxter A (1998) Condition Factor, K, for Salmonid Fish. Fisheries Notes 1-3.
- Bolarinwa J B (2017) Length-Weight Relationships and Condition Factors of Cynoglossuscynoglossus and Caranx Hippos in Epe Lagoon, Nigeria. International Journal of Research in Agriculture and Forestry 4(3): 1-5.
- Bharadhirajan P, Mahadevan G, Murugesan P, Murugan S, Pouladi M, et al. (2019) Relative condition factor, length-weight relationship, and growth of three-spotted flounder, Pseudorhombus triocellatus (Bloch & Schneider, 1801) from Parangipettai Coast, India. Biodiversitas Journal of Biological Diversity 20: 373-379.
- Abowei J F N (2009) The morphology, abundance, condition factor and length-weight relationship of Ethmalosafimbriata (Bowdish 1825) from Nkoro River Niger Delta, Nigeria. Advance Journal of Food Science and Technology 1(1): 51-56.
- Parihar D, Saksena D N, Rao R J (2016) Seasonal variations in condition factor and feeding intensity of freshwater teleost: Ompokbimaculatus, Xenentodoncancila, Puntiussarana and Labeoboggut from Tighra reservoir, Gwalior (MP). Inter J Advanced Life Sci 9(3): 344-350.
- Zare P, Naderi M, Azvar E (2013) Length–weight relationships of 10 fish species collected from stake traps in the muddy shores of the inter‐tidal zone of Bandar Abbas city, Persian Gulf, Iran. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 29(1): 288-289.
- Gupta B K, Sarkar U K, Bhardwaj S K, Pal A (2011) Condition factor, length-weight and length-weight relationships of an endangered fish Ompokpabda (Hamilton 1822) (Silurifomes: Siluridae) from the River Gomti, a tributary of the River Ganga, India. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 27: 962-964.
- Cherif M, Zarrad R, Gharbi H, Missaoui H, Jarboui O (2008) Length-weight relationships for fish species from the Gulf of Tunis (SW Mediterranean Sea, Tunisia). Pan American Journal of Aquatic Sciences 3(1): 1-5.
- Ozaydin O, Uckun D, Akalin S, Leblebici S, Tosunoglu Z (2007) Length-weight relationships of fishes captured from Izmir Bay, Central Aegean Sea. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 23: 695-696.
- Veiga P, Machado D, Almeida C, Bentes L, Monteiro P, et al. (2009) Weight-length relationships for 54 species of the Arade Estuary, Southern Portugal. Journal of Applied Ichthyology 25(4): 493-496.
- Gabriela G C, Meiners C, Jiménez-Badillo L (2015) Length-weight relationships for 30 fish species caught in coastal waters of Veracruz, western Gulf of Mexico Relaciones de longitud-peso para 30 especies de peces capturada senaguas costeras de Veracruz, Oeste del Golfo de Mé Revista de Biología Marina Oceanografía 50(1): 141-147.