Open Access Journal of Neurology & Neurosurgery |Neurology Journals Impact Factor List

Research Article

Cerebellopontine Angle Tumors; Tumor Size and Surgical Outcome

Mazin S Mohammed Jawad*

Department of neurosurgery, Private nursing home hospital, Iraq

Submission: March 03, 2017; Published: May 04, 2017

*Corresponding author: Mazin S Mohammed Jawad, Department of Neurosurgeon, Private nursing home hospital, Iraq, Tel: 009647706229469; Email: mazinsaad11@Gmail.com

How to cite this article: Mazin S M J. Cerebellopontine Angle Tumors; Tumor Size and Surgical Outcome. Open Access J Neurol Neurosurg. 2017; 3(4): 555617. DOI: 10.19080/OAJNN.2017.03.555617

Abstract

Object: Our object is to illustrate the various aspects of clinical presentation and surgical complications with linkage to the tumor size regarding cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumors.

Materials and method: This is a prospective study of 30 patients at the Neurosurgical department / Medical city, with mean age of 36 years with CPA tumors (predominantly acoustic neuroma) that underwent surgical removal using a suboccipital retrosigmoid approach over a 1-year period (2015 / 2016).

Results: There was a female preponderance. The most common presentation was vertigo followed by tinnitus. There were two cases (6%) of cerebrospinal fluid leak. Facial nerve function was measured by the House Brackmann (HB) system and function further classified into three categories: excellent (HB I-II), intermediate (HB III-IV), and poor (HB V-VI) outcome following surgery, showing that all cases below 20 mm tumor size have an excellent outcome and (67%) of cases with > 20 mm tumor size shows poor outcome. One death in this study (mortality rate, 3%) was due to respiratory cessation.

Conclusion: Significant correlation between tumor size and facial nerve outcome, with larger C.P.A. tumors yield worse outcomes. Tumor size also influences the development of CSF leak and operative morbidity and mortality.

Keywords: Cerebellopontine angle tumors; Facial nerve; CSF leak

Introduction

Cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumors are the most common neoplasms in the posterior fossa, accounting for 10-15% of intracranial tumors. Most CPA tumors are benign, with 80-94% being vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas), lipomas, vascular malformations, and hemangiomas. The most frequent nonacoustic CPA tumors are meningiomas (3-10%), epidermoids (primary cholesteatomas) (2- 4%), and facial or lower cranial nerve schwannomas. Primary malignancies or metastatic lesions account for less than 2% of neoplasms in the CPA [1]. Early in the 20th century, CPA lesions were difficult to diagnose and rarely completely excised. Indeed, the mortality rate for operative intervention in the posterior fossa approached 50%. However, revolutionary advances in neuroradiologic imaging and surgical techniques and approaches have made these lesions almost uniformly treatable with acceptable morbidity and very low rates of mortality. Surgical intervention remains the most definitive means for complete tumor removal for most of these lesions. Radiation therapy has gained popularity to arrest tumor growth with specific tumor types and is also an option for patients who are unwilling or medically unable to undergo surgery [2].

There is tendency for patients diagnosed with vestibular schwannoma to be white, aged 50-60 years, and in a professional occupation, but there seemed to be no specific sex preference in the disease. A strong association appeared to exist between hay fever and vestibular schwannoma, while tobacco use seemed to have an inverse relationship to the likelihood of developing the condition [3]. Surgical approaches vary depending on the pathologic entity as well as the size and involvement of adjacent structures. Although complete excision is planned for most cases, the intimate involvement of surrounding structures may impose unwarranted morbidity if complete excision is attempted. Meningiomas are excised completely more readily than epidermoids, whereas adequate therapy for arachnoid cysts is drainage [4]. Standard approaches to the CPA include the translabyrinthine, suboccipital (retrosigmoid), or middle fossa craniotomies (see Skull Base, Acoustic Neuroma (Vestibular Schwannoma). The choice of approach is based on specific location and hearing status. Occasionally, these craniotomies can be combined or performed in addition to an infratemporal fossa dissection for larger tumors [4]. The outcome and prognosis for cure from surgical resection depends on the histology, size, and location of the tumor and the approach chosen. Cessation of tumor growth from primary radiation also depends on the specific factors listed above. Expected facial palsy rates are high for primary facial schwannomas. The effect on quality of life from facial nerve palsy is quite significant. Results also depend on the experience and skills of the surgeon [5].

Materials and Methods

This is a prospective study of 30 patients at the Neurosurgical department / Medical city between Sept. 2015 and Sept. 2016, were carried out and undergoing surgical removal using the suboccipital retrosigmoid approach. MRI Was done for all patients for the radiological diagnosis. The data collected in each patient included the patient's age, gender, size of tumor and postoperative complications. Tumors sizes divided into 3 categories (1-10 mm, 11-20mm,>20mm) and pre operative symptoms was categorized in relation to the tumor size. Facial nerve function was graded according to the House Brackmann scale (HB) after surgery and allocated into three categories: excellent (HB I-II), intermediate (HB III-IV), and poor (HB V-VI) outcomes.

Results

30 patients with a mean age of 36 years (range, 20-65 years) were included in this study. The histopathological diagnosis of CPA tumors in which acoustic neuroma represents 70% of all cases followed by meningioma 20% while epidermoid cyst, astrocytoma and lipoma represented in 10% of cases. There is an overall female predominance (60%), χ2 (10.1816) and P-value (0.006153) at p < 0.05 which is significant statistically.
MRI Was done for all patients for the radiological diagnosis. The suboccipital retrosigmoid approach was the standard procedure in all cases described in our study.
The mean tumor size was 18mm, ranging from <10mm to >20mm, χ2 (11.2667) and P-value (0.023725) at p < 0.05 as shown in Figure 1.

i. 2 (11.2667), P-value (0.023725) , p < 0.05

In our study we found that twenty three patients (76.6%) presented with vertigo while tinnitus presented in 14 patients (46.6%). In both previous groups, the majority of patients (25 patients) had tumors with 11- 20mm in maximum diameter. Five patients had facial palsy preoperatively with mean tumor size of 20mm. This is statically significant χ2 (13.9751) and P-value (0.007375) at p <

a.(Table 1).

χ2 (13.9751), P-value (0.007375), p < 0.05.
Facial nerve function was graded according to the House Brackmann scale (HB) after surgery. Function was further classified into three categories: excellent (HB I-II), intermediate (HB III-IV), and poor (HB V-VI) outcomes. Twenty-five patients had an excellent and 4 had a poor facial nerve functional outcome. All cases below 20mm tumor size have an excellent outcome and (67%) of cases with > 20mm tumor size shows poor outcome this is of great significance, χ2 is 22.272, the p-value is 0.000015 at p < 0.05. The results are summarized in (Table 2).

χ2 is 22.272. The p-value is 0.000015, p < 0.05.
There is a significant correlation between tumor size and facial nerve outcome, with larger tumors yielding worse outcomes. Table 2 illustrates this relationship, comparing facial nerve outcome with tumor size.
CSF leakage occurred in two patients (6%).These cases were handled conservatively with application of wound dressing and bed rest the mean tumor size in patients with CSF leaks was 25mm, compared with 15mm in patients without CSF leaks,χ2 is 8.5714, the p-value is 0.003415 at p < 0.05 this give a strong evidence of correlation between tumor size and CSF leak.
Bacterial meningitis was indicated by the presence of the classic symptoms and was confirmed by CSF analysis. Of the 2 patients diagnosed with CSF leakage in this series, one had concomitant bacterial meningitis resolved with intravenous antibiotic therapy, χ2 is 4.1379 and p-value is 0.041932 at p < 0.05 which is significant.
There was one death in this series (mortality rate, 3%), χ2 is 14.4828 and p-value is 0.000141 at p < 0.05, which was due to respiratory failure.

Discussion

In our study, acoustic neuroma constituent of about (70%), and meningioma (20%) and those readings are close to the study made by Thaba BK et al. BSMMU, Dhaka where acoustic neuroma represents 77% and Meningioma 15 % [6].
Mainly vertigo and tinnitus are the main presentations in our study, 76.6% and 46.6% respectively as most of our patients 70% referred from both neurologist and otolaryngologist. In the literature, reports of balance disorder in vestibular schwannoma schwannoma vary widely. Some authors maintain it may be the presenting symptom in 15% of cases. Continuous or intermittent tinnitus with concomitant hearing loss is present in approximately 90% of cases, and is nearly always unilateral [7].
Tinnitus which has generally been found in association with hearing loss in other series like the one of Moffat et al., and Thomas NW, although others have also pointed out that it is also an infrequent complaint in non-acoustic cerebellopontine angle lesions [8]. We have found 46.6% of cases of vertigo such as have been reported by Lalwani AK et al. [6-9].
Suboccipital retrosigmoid approach was the standard procedure in all cases described in our study, this
Reflects our neurosurgical department standards and the familiarity of the approach access. Similarly Glasscock et al. reported on the retro mastoid and middle fossa approaches in 161 selected patients. They found a lower incidence of temporary facial nerve paresis using the retrosigmoid approach [10]. Mazzoni et al. reported on a selected series of 90 of 300 patients operated on using the retro mastoid approach for a trial of preservation of hearing. The facial nerve was preserved in 99%, with completely normal function in 78%. The cochlear nerve was anatomically preserved in 96% and functionally in 44% [11].
Rates of CSF leakage have fallen dramatically according to refinement of surgical techniques. Previously reported rates of 20% have declined with the use of fat packing into the mastoid region and obliteration of the Eustachian tube and middle ear space [12]. In our series, CSF leaks developed in 6% of patients, patients with ventricular enlargement where shunted preoperatively with ventriculo-peritoneal shunt also using of fascia tight closure with closing of wound in layers.This rate is comparable with other recent series that have placed rates at 6-16% [12]. We found that tumor size can influence the development of CSF leaks. Both Slattery et al. [13] and Brennan et al. [14], found a significant relationship between tumor size and the prevalence of CSF leakage; according to Brennan et al. [14] larger tumors appeared to lead to a greater risk of CSF leak; however, Slattery et al. [13] showed a correlation between surgical approach and CSF leakage rate, with a retrosigmoid approach having the highest frequency (15%) and middle fossa approach the lowest (5.7%) [13]. Based on these findings, it can be concluded that tumor size and type of surgical approach are the main factors affecting postoperative CSF leakage.
Our study shows a clear correlation between increasing tumor size and worsening facial nerve outcome. This is not surprising, as larger tumors tend to become more intimately involved with the facial nerve or significantly alter its course. Studies show that both the type of surgical approach and tumor size are the main factors significantly affecting postoperative facial nerve function [15]. The anatomical facial nerve preservation rate has been reported to be 80-90% [15]. The preservation of facial nerve function has been reported to be 70-80% for tumors greater than 3cm in diameter, removed either by the retrosigmoid [15]. The reported preservation rate of "excellent" function after the removal of large tumors is 42-52.6% [15]. Which is comparable to our study 50% for tumors > 20mm.
Bacterial meningitis encountered in one patient in our study who had concomitantly a CSF leak which
give attention to the aggressive measures to prevent and to treat the CSF leak both intra and post operatively. Though the 3% meningitis (one patient) if compared to other studies [16] it's so promising and with high positive predictive value.
The 3% mortality following operation the cause was due to respiratory failure, the patient was heavy smoker with borderline respiratory function test. If compared to figures reported in the literatures, it can be justified taking in consideration, the high percentage of late presentation, the availability of the diagnostic aids the lack of intra-operative monitoring shows that the mortality dropped from 85% in Hensches cases reported in 1910 to 4% by Cushing 22 years later [11-17].

Conclusion

Cerebellopontine angle tumors size influences the development of both intra and posts operative complications operative morbidity and mortality. There is obvious and significant correlation between tumor size and post operative facial nerve outcome, CSF leak with larger C.P.A. tumors yield worse outcomes.