1Research and Practice Center of Preventive and Clinical Medicine, Ukraine
1Chuiko Institute of Surface Chemistry, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Ukraine
1Chuiko Institute of Surface Chemistry, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Ukraine
Submission: April 30, 2018; Published: May 22, 2018
*Corresponding author: Vitalii Zaft, State Institution of Science “Research and Practice Center of Preventive and Clinical Medicine” State Administrative Department, Kyiv, Ukraine, Tel: +380965561481; Email: [email protected]
How to cite this article: Boiko IV, Zaft VB, Lazarenko GO, Lazarenko OM, Aleksyeyeva TA, Kartel NT. et al. Testing the Compatibility of the Orthopedic
Implants Material with the Recipient’s Body in Arthroplastic Using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). JOJ Orthoped Ortho Surg. 2018; 1(5): 555571. DOI: 10.19080/JOJOOS.2018.01.555571
This article describes the method of preoperative testing of orthopedic implants material for compatibility with recipient’s body by using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) and research the influence of tissue reactions on the implant’s surface.
Keywords: Implants; Biocompatibility; Testing of material; Atomic force microscopy
Every year orthopedic surgeons perform about 2,500,000 operation arthroplasty on various joints. In Europe in the past 5 years, the number of surgical operations in the endoprosthesis has increased by 80%. Orthopedic doctors used the big spectra of implants which consist of (endoprotes of the thigh, knee, shoulder, elbow joint, joints on the ankles and even small joints of the feet and fingers). Unfortunately, each of these implants is foreign body for our organism. Rejection reaction or manifestation of hypersensitivity to the implant material is observed in 6 - 30% of cases of surgical intervention [1-15]. Immune reaction is one of the causes of complications of bone tissue on implants. The rejection reaction to the body on exogenous materials (implants) is manifested as a local aseptic inflammation with the formation of a fibro capsule around them, that leading to loss of their functional properties. The recipient organism reaction to foreign body depends on both branches of immune system, and particular importance to them has the absorption of immunoglobulins class G (IgG) and reaction of the body cells to surface of the implants .
Certain electron in homogeneity of the surface of materials plays the role of the binding centers of Ig and cells. Adhesion of IgG on surface of the implants provokes to the activation of the immune system, that leading to the development of persistent non-infectious (aseptic) inflammation. Material of implants that contact with the recipient organism determined by allocation of the last anti-inflammatory mediators like interleukin-1 and interleukin-6, which cause the process that can leads to selective dissolution of the components of implants and, in the future, it can cause to the destruction of implant. Selective dissolution of implants products can lead to toxic effects on cells, or stimulate synthesis of some proteins. Absorption or accumulation proteins of various toxic substances, protein complexes with nickel, chromium and cobalt ions, and formation around the material dense layer of the extracellular matrix, is important for the biological behavior of the material (attachment cells or bacteria to surface of materials).
Adhesion of proteins depends on the chemical properties of the material, and on its physical characteristics (wettability, superficial energy, etc.). Creating of expressive physical method for controlling of the compatibility of materials according is extremely necessary. In addition, the possibility of individual selection of materials, taking into account the immune status of the recipient organism, raises the problem of certification of materials to a qualitatively new level [11,12,16]. The purpose of study was determine the possibility of using Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) for predict the reaction of the organism to the implant (foreign body).
In newer present methods that are available for investigating internal and intermolecular forces acting between bimolecular. The AFM are the most effective research tool. This method covers a range of entropy forces in Femto-Newtons (1015 Newtons) for
determine the force required to break covalent bonds in several
nano-Newtons (10-9 Newtons). The Atomic Force Microscope
(AFM), allows you to determine the strength of the interaction
Antigen - Antibody and structure of individual macromolecules,
such as DNA (intra-molecular forces) [16,17]. A wide range of
controlled interactions creates real prerequisites for successful
solving of a number of applied problems with the help of
nanobiosensory technologies implemented on the hardware
software basis of AFM. In recent years, have been made
convincing attempts to use AFM for the diagnosis of cancer that
based on the testing of the specific adhesion of IgG to malignant
cells and their contact elasticity.
The AFM study of bioadhesive separation force was
carried out on a scanning probe microscope Dimension 3000
NanoScopeIIIa (Veecocorp.) Both in air (at a temperature of
22oС and a relative humidity of 30%) and in a liquid medium
(0.9% solution of sodium chloride). The velocity of the vertical
movement of the probe selected in the range from 20 to 20,000
nm/sec. For measurements, used contact probes from SiNNDNP-
20 (VeecoInc.) with V-shaped cantilever. The average radius
of the edge of the probe 30 nm, the cantilever’s rigidity 0.06 N /
m. The control of the form of the tip performed before and after
measurements using the “blind reconstruction” method using
the test grid TGT-1 (NT-MDT). Clarification of the value of the cantilever hardness was carried out by analyzing the spectrum
of its temperature noise.
The scheme of measurements is presented in Figure 1. At
the initial moment, the probe modified by the antibody (AT) is
far from the surface of the sample (point 1) and the interaction
surface of the surface-AT is zero. Next, the AFM system of
vertical movement of the probe leads the probe to the surface,
controlling the distance to the accuracy of the angstrom (10-10
m). At a certain minimum distance between the probe and the
surface, the “capture” of the modified probe is carried out by the
surface under the action of the attraction forces (point 2). With
further approximation of the probe and the surface begins to act
repulsive forces that prevent the penetration of the probe into
the surface. After reaching the maximum value of the repulsion
force given by the operator based on the conditions of the
experiment (point 3) begins the inverse vertical movement of
the probe. At the same time, the surplus of all the forces holding
the modified probe near the surface is balanced by the force of
elastic deformation of the probe console at the point 4, in which
there is a separation from the surface. Thus, the maximum
value of the force of the bioadgezial interaction corresponds to
the magnitude of the detachment force of the probe from the
surface (point 4), which is equal to the strength of the elastic
deformation of the probe console, measured by the detection
system of the AFM, by the value of its deflection d (Figure 1).
For modified of the surfaces of probe were applied
antibodies. As antibodies used total IgG, which were isolated
from the serum of the patient’s blood. AB was applied to the
ACM with a solution at a concentration of 0.1 μg / ml. (0.9%
NaCl solution). The measurements were carried out both in air
and in water, in order to check the difference between the data
obtained, whether they are essential for the evaluation of the
bioadhesion forces. During measurements in the atmosphere on
the surface of the sample due to the presence of capillary forces,
a so-called capillary bridge is formed, which makes a significant
contribution to the amount of adhesive forces. Thus, the value
of separation strength when measured in the air is greater
than during measurements in water. However, as it has been
established, qualitative correlations between the values of the
separation forces for different samples are retained. In clinical
trials included patients, with joint diseases, that in future will
have arthroplasty according to treatment protocols.
In the perioperative period, sampling of 5 ml of patient’s
venous blood is performed in vacuum container, from which was
prepared serum, according to the standard method, was isolated
total IgG . After purification and dilution, an appropriate
concentration of IgG, 2 μg/ml, is applied to the AFM probe.
The probes with the applied IgG patient were tested for the
compatibility of the implant material with the patient’s body.
The value of the confinement of probe with IgG of recipient
to the surface of the implant was considered to evaluate the
compatibility of the material with the patient’s body. The higher
value of the strength retention, more likely development of the
reaction of implant rejection by the organism. The basis for the
hip implant was the titanium alloy Ti6Al4V, the characteristics of
which are given in Table 1.
For the period 2015-2016, in the clinic of the State Institution
of Science “Research and Practice Center of Preventive and
Clinical Medicine” State Administrative Department, was
performed a test of the compatibility of the material of
orthopedic implants in endoprosthetics of large joints with the
recipient organism with the help of AFM in 11 patients [13,18].
Patients underwent surgical intervention (arthroplasty of the
hip and knee joints). In Table 2 show the strength of the IgG
surface of the prosthetic element. The force of confinement clean
probe with the surface of the implant ranged from 5-8 nN. Thus,
according to the AFM, one can confidently say that in all cases
the recipient develops a local aseptic inflammation at the site of
the implant. Reliability of the obtained values p ≤ 0,005. Listed in
Table 3 data suggest that in the course of time, the patient only
increases the CRP and the number of segmental neutrophils. And
the results of testing with AFM remain at 49-56 nN, which testify
to the constant reaction of the organism to the implant. So the
stress of immune system of this patient is constantly maintained
by the presence of the implant, and the specificity of IgG to the
prosthesis remains very high.
The variety of the reaction of the receptor’s tissues to the
foreign body that is introduced into the body depends on its
immune status and the primary reaction of the cells of the body
to the surface of the implants is of particular importance .
The development of modern high-tech branches of medicine,
including orthopedics, traumatology and dentistry, places
high demands on the quality of implantable materials. The
main of them - medical and biological, based on the absence
of toxic, carcinogenic and corrosive properties in the material.
Biomaterials should be biocompatible and have the technological
qualities that allow, in the case of a certain treatment, to obtain
the necessary structure that is characterized by frictional
stability and low thermal conductivity [15,19]. At the same time,
implant materials should perform not only substitution function,
but gradually integrate into the surrounding bone, promote the
formation and remodeling of bone tissue.
Scientific evidence suggests that activation of developments
in the creation of new and improved known biomaterials
for medicine [10,11,17]. It should be noted that even a minor
modification of the biomaterial (elemental composition, phase
state, topography and surface structure, etc.) can significantly
alter its properties. Therefore, the medical-biological research of
artificial biomaterials remains relevant and significant [15,17].
An approach developed to solve the problem of individual
prediction of the degree of compatibility of implant materials
with the recipient organism on the basis of nanobiosensors
controlled by the AFM hardware and software system is
appropriate and relevant. Today, the development of optimal
conditions for nanobiosensory testing of implants with AFM and
the study of the effects of reactions of tissues of the recipient
on the surface of implants will significantly increase the
effectiveness of surgical treatment of diseases of the locomotor
system by selecting / selecting optimally compatible implants
with the recipient organism [8,9,17,20].
Development of optimal conditions for testing the implant
with the body of the recipient using Atomic Force Microscopy
(AFM) will significantly increase the effectiveness of surgical
treatment of orthopedic disorders.
The method of testing the compatibility of the implant
material with the recipient’s body using AFM can allow:
a. At the preoperative stage, determine the possibility of
occurrence of processes of rejection of the implant.
b. Provide compatibility with body implants and choose
the most appropriate and / or to provide drugs to prevent
c. Data received through research, allow the doctor to
choose the necessary tactics of patients in the postoperative